5d ago

Once in a Generation Person

You're viewing a single thread.

189 comments

These Gazans are going to get eliminated, nobody wants to help them, just ask Kuwait and Lebanon. Israels tolerance for terrorism was the only reason they were still alive to begin with, and the murder spree has broken that tolerance.
Imagine if you were an Israeli citizen and there were religious fanatics coming into your towns and murdering and kidnapping everyone, what would be your response and expectation of your government?
- You missed the part in which Israeli citizens get indoctrinated since kindergarten and the one in which they have been trying to colonize whatever is around them because their imaginary friends told them to.
  
  Well your country may have been on stolen land, what if you had a group of people near you that wanted to take the land back by force; are you willing to give up your own house?
  The whole question is absurd, you're not going to, and you're also not going to let them continue attacking you, because your desire to save your family from rape and murder is greater than your empathy.
  
  if I was living in a stolen house then yes, I would rather our government come to a fair agreement with the people... to act as if we'd all just condone a genocide when many of us don't even have a say in the matter is just nonsensical.
  you're trying to rationalize away an active genocide like it's still the era of colonization...which again was wrong
  i think we should form sub nations with the Indians we dominated over here but we're wAyyy too late for that, we're not for this.its something actively going on. you seem to be forgetting that part
  
  So you live on indigenous land you're saying, but you're not in a stolen house?
  
  palestinians were established well before israel existed.
  
  are you willing to give up your own house?
  That argument falls when it's well-known that the gov deliberately pushes efforts for more illegal settlements... so yeah, not really your house..
  
  If my house was built on land that was taken after murdering the people there, then I would deserve to have my house burned down, feelings are irrelevant.
  
  So non-native Canadians and the Americans should give up all their land back to the indigenous and move back to Europe?
  
  Well yes, in practice that's not feasible, but we should be giving land back to native groups. In reality humans have migrated throughout history, I don't disagree with the concept of settling necessarily but groups that were subject to genocide and forced expulsion deserve reparations.
  
  When are you going to drop the "won't somebody please think of the children" bomb?
- You mean; imagine you were a Palestinian citizen and religious fanatics came into multiple West Bank towns in summer 2023 and set them on fire, and it turns out the Israeli government actively supported the attacks and sent the military to back those settlers and shoot any Palestinians who fought back against the settlers. What would be your response and expectation?
  It always amazes me how Israelis act as if October 7 happened completely out of the blue unprovoked. The first 9 months of 2023 was the deadliest year for Palestinians in 20 years with over 240 dead, and the Israeli government refused to prosecute any settlers and instead armed them further. Even the Pope got involved in September 2023 to formally condemn Israeli settlers for vandalizing churches and Ben Gvir defended the attacks saying it was revenge on Christian anti-semitism. Every Palestinian was aware of these attacks, even Hamas threatened to retaliate if the attacks on West Bank towns didn’t stop and Netanyahu decided to do respond by further increasing settler support.
- Anyone who acts in the name of god is using delusion to justify madness. There is no third party. We are all each a part of the larger whole.
  Hot take: we all have the devine right to exist, no exceptions. If Israeli citizens are so religious and devine, where is the humanity, love and compassion for the women and children of Gaza? The media is pumping out anti-humanism rhetoric, imaging the Palestinian as less than human. An animal. But these are opinions of comfortable people with access to internet, shelter, food and water. Imagine when the new children of Israel actually get to Gaza, and realise what they have done.
- wasnt the kurds also left to get slaughtered too.

189 comments