These Prisoners Are Training AI
These Prisoners Are Training AI
In high-wage Finland, where clickworkers are rare, one company has discovered a novel labor force—prisoners.
Didn't the AI hypers tell us that AI would boost the economy by a lot and that it's a multi-trillion dollar opportunity? Turns out it (too) relies on modern slavery to be profitable.
(OpenAI/Microsoft do a similar thing but with Nigerian workers: https://time.com/6247678/openai-chatgpt-kenya-workers/)
23This is an interesting idea, but I'm still a bit irked about prison labor.
I understand that this permits productive ways to pass time, but the wages per hour are atrocious. It reminds me of the 13th amendment of the US Constitution:
"Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction."
20I agree, especially in the US, with large brands taking advantage.
Don't the wages reflect that they have no bills to pay though?
8Don’t the wages reflect that they have no bills to pay though?
I mean that'd be fine if they weren't charged absolutely unreasonable prices for everything they have to buy.
Prisoners are paid on average $0.14 to $1.41 per hour (depending on state and job), according to this website.
Even a fucking phone call cost prisoners $10-$15 per 15 minutes until Biden put a cap on it this year, and it's still $3 per 15 minutes. So basically, a prisoner needs to work for at least 2 hours and in some cases as much as 21 hours, to earn the privilege of a 15 minute phone call? Come the fuck on. Nevermind the price of commissary items.
I can understand not paying prisoners $25 / hr or whatever, but $5-$7 would still be low but far more reasonable rates. Further, if a fucking private corporation is using prison labor, IMO they should be paying the normal market rate for labor in that industry, even if some of it is put into a fund in the prisoner's name and released to them when they're released from prison. (This might actually help recidivism, as prisoners would have some money to help them get back on their feet when they were released; that's pure speculation, though, and I have no source to back it up.)
13
eh ... this might create some interesting biases in the training data ...
11Might as well. If I was stuck in a cage for most of my day, I'd be happy to mindlessly click around a computer.
But, I am adhd, so I might be the weird one.
7Im guessing its gonna be like endlessly solving captchas. And i hate doing that
4I've gotten used to it since websites hate my VPN. Especially Google who makes me solve like 10 of them
1
"now that's a scary number!" /em drags into box
4
4
Finally found the solution to the alignment problem
2Weve spent so much time worry about how to align it we never stopped to think what we should align it to
5