Skip Navigation

Motorcycles should be banned entirely

There's no good reason for them to be on the road. Consider the following:

  • They're extremely loud and cause noise pollution
  • They're very dangerous on the road and have high accident rates
  • They're bad for the environment and cause air pollution
  • They're extremely inefficient as they can only carry 1-2 people max
  • They can't carry cargo
  • They're dangerous for pedestrians
  • They're very demanding to operate
  • They're virtually useless in the winter when there's snow, ice, and hail
  • The people who tend to drive them tend to be assholes who don't respect road laws

People complain about cars all the time, and while our car dependency is definitely a big issue that we need to address, cars still have a lot utility. Motorcycles on the other hand? Not really. I think getting rid of them once and for all is good way to immediately make our roads safer, simplify traffic, and open up a pathway to move away from cars.

49 comments
  • I don't know, most of these points also apply to cars, if not more so to cars, and this “motorcyclists are assholes” is complete nonsense. It's not an unpopular opinion, it's just a terrible, flawed, biased opinion.

  • Motorcycle is a broad category, most e-bikes fit under it. The defining characteristics is a motor vehicle steered by handlebar from a saddle style seat.

    They don’t have to be loud, but many drivers intentionally choose to make them loud. This comes down to a cultural issue, more about that later. Arguably most sports cars are much more obnoxious.

    The accident rate and danger tends to come down more to cars than to motorcycles them selves. Most deadly motorcycle accidents are collisions with cars, and most of those are deemed the fault of the car driver. They’re also unreasonably fast for the form factor, again, because they have to mingle with cars, particularly on the highway.

    Motorcycles are held to the same emission standards as cars, unless it’s not a road legal vehicle like a dirt bike, or not fast/powerful enough to require a license, like a moped. And they’re generally way more fuel efficient than cars due to being physically smaller, most getting between 70 to 90 MPG. Even Harley’s, intentionally outdated and inefficient designs, get 45MPG better than most cars.

    Most can fit 2 people, which is more than most cars tend to have in them at any given time, and with pannier bags they can carry more than most cars will carry on a day to day basis, with most people never carrying cargo in their car beyond a few grocery bags.

    They’re statistically much less dangerous to pedestrians than cars. I have no idea where you got the idea they’re more dangerous to pedestrians from.

    They’re generally actually much easier to maintain than a car being smaller and less mechanically complex. The reason that so many motorcyclists tend to spend a lot of time maintain them is because they’re doing more of it them selves rather than taking it to a dealership or a mechanic.

    There is absolutely a cultural issue among motorcyclists, but much of that comes down to how often they’re nearly killed by inattentive drivers. Constantly being put in danger by car drivers not paying attention tends to make people a bit hostile to car drivers. Much of the rest comes down to the fact that such a risky activity tends to attract people who are in to it to seem “cool”, which will attract some shitty people.

  • Yeah, people should have small, quiet, electric motorcycles ridden by educated and defensive drivers with winter tires.

    I had a two-stroke motorcycle that I rode to school all year round and yeah, I'd argue for bans on ICEs in motorcycles, harsher noise pollution/road safety laws/monitoring now.

    They're extremely loud and cause noise pollution

    Combustion engines do that, two-wheeled motor vehicles can be built quiet.

    They're very dangerous on the road and have high accident rates

    IIRC, most fatal accidents involving motorcycles result in motorcycle driver death, not so much others. Limiting speed or power (especially for young and learning drivers) might reduce fatalities.

    They're bad for the environment and cause air pollution

    ICE engines. One point for road infrastructure in general (tires, asphalt), although their PM/NOx emissions should be compared to trucks or trains.

    They're extremely inefficient as they can only carry 1-2 people max

    Inefficient in what way?

    They can't carry cargo

    I think you know this is a bad argument.

    They're dangerous for pedestrians

    What motorised vehicle isn't? Which vehicle infrastructure isn't? This one is oddly specific.

    They're very demanding to operate

    Yes. I always saw that as a good thing, because it meant that I wouldn't drive when I couldn't or shouldn't attention-wise.

    They're virtually useless in the winter when there's snow, ice, and hail

    Gear, restraint and skill issue. I found autumn rain much more dangerous.

    The people who tend to drive them tend to be assholes who don't respect road laws

    True that.

  • I just had a vision of a European city where all motorcycles are instantly replaced by cars and I think I need a shower.

  • They follow all legal noise limits same as every other vehicle

    Its the riders right to risk their own life that's called liberty

    For co2 Car: 166 g/passenger km, Motorcycle: 113 g/passenger km

    Efficiency wise u clearly don't understand what a relative measure is. Also see prevouse point about co2

    That's a personal choice

    They are less dangerous for pedestrian (learn about inertia)

    Again its ur right to inconvenience yourself (a pedal bycicle is more demanding than a motorbike should be ban them as well)

    See previous point

    If u wanna make an argument rooted in "people who do bad thing xyz tend to be abc" can be used to justify racism (Google what proportion of crime in us is committed by black people) therefore shit argument

    I get that this is unpopular opinions and that's fine ur welcome to have an unpopular OPINION but ur just flat out factually wrong/have no regard for personal liberty.

49 comments