How Star Trek: Voyager Failed In The Face Of Easy Success
How Star Trek: Voyager Failed In The Face Of Easy Success
www.giantfreakinrobot.com
How Star Trek: Voyager Failed In The Face Of Easy Success
14 comments
-
-
This guy seems that he has specialised in pointing out all the flaws in a show in a way that if you know nothing about the show you could think it didn't last one season.
He has an entire series of articles called why it failed.
The show was so bad that he watched all seven seasons multiple times.
-
Complete tv series that finished its run and ended when they wanted to how the fuck is that a failure?
-
how the fuck is that a failure?
They didn't get rid of neelix until the second to last episode
-
-
The only way Voyager failed was in the hilariously rushed and silly ending. Otherwise it's just more solid Trek, warts and all.
-
Voyager is my 2nd favorite behind TNG.
Also Voyager is a great Lemmy/Piefed app :)
-
Do you like DS9?
-
Yes. I also enjoyed DS9 very much. I guess that would land 3rd for me. Although I know a lot of people like it the most.
-
-
-
Terrible article.
14 comments
No.
The title of this is enticing, but just like the claim made in it, the article fails to deliver.
Chakotay’s character Isn’t racist; it is uninspired. B’lanna is not even remotely close to the “worst” Voyager character. Janeway should have been a healthy blend of Kirk, Picard, and Sisko, not just “more Kirk”.
I think it is extremely easy to critique Voyager with a current lens, but much of its issues stem from the 90s and Jeri Taylor’s exit, as well being the first Trek wholly owned by the network and not allowed to do its own thing like its predecessors.
I agree on most of those counts, except the Chakotay one is actually very real; if you didn’t fully read the article (and I knew this already before reading it), a “Native American” cultural consultant, only to fond out the dude was a complete phony, so nearly everything that show depicts of Chakotay’s culture is either pulled from stereotypes or made up entirely.
I was aware of the consultant prior as well, but the fact that they made an attempt wasn’t necessarily racist. We’re talking about cultures that have evolved 400+ years from our own, so they could have come up with anything at all, especially considering that Chakotay didn’t grow up on Earth. They chose not to pursue his background at all, and then chose not to develop him from there, when they had the choice to do anything.