Ohio State University health sciences course requires students to engage with ‘White Privilege Knapsack’
Ohio State University health sciences course requires students to engage with ‘White Privilege Knapsack’
Students were required to address ‘whiteness’ and describe what the term ‘white’ means, as well as explain how they ‘navigate race’ in their daily lives.
Students were required to address ‘whiteness’ and describe what the term ‘white’ means, as well as explain how they ‘navigate race’ in their daily lives.
Wow, what a garbage article. Surprise surprise it's origin was Fox News. The amount of sarcasm quotes is kind of impressive, though.
Gods forbid you have to take a look at your privileges then unpack what that means. Oh, and then you have to try and empathize with people that don't have those same privileges. Scandalous.
34Not that having privilege personally is a bad thing either. It's just opening you up to it, being aware of it. It also doesn't diminish other negative things you went through.
I'm a white male. I probably have gotten jobs that were helped by that fact. I also grew up dirt poor only affording ramen and rice. One does not cancel the other out, it just adds to who I am.
However now being aware of it I want to move into a position where I can help change things, where I can help hire people not based on their skin color or sex
11Exactly. Right wingers are so afraid of admitting they have any privilege. Like, it doesn't make you a bad person inherently
10I also grew up dirt poor only affording ramen and rice.
If nothing else, we can acknowledge that choosing to eat Ramen and rice now is not the outcome for a lot of people who tried just as hard as we did to move up the economic ladder. They are often still stuck in the same position because of things outside their control.
5
Wow, what a garbage article. Surprise surprise it’s origin was Fox News. The amount of sarcasm quotes is kind of impressive, though.
I totally agree about what you say on fox news. I would honestly like to ask you something. Since I am not a native english speaker I am afraid that I must have missed the amount of sarcasm you mention. Would you mind pointing out a few examples so that I have a compass for the future. And I will delete it afterwards.
[edit: I was looking for a better article on the topic but I didn't find one yet. If anyone has something in mind, please add a comment and I will edit the post and add this link, instead of deleting it as mentioned above]
7Any single word in quotation marks. Reread sentences with any single word in quotes as if some conservative know-it-all is rolling their eyes and scoffing at these quoted terms. Putting them in quotes quarantines them from having to be taken seriously and is setting them up for criticism. If they didn't use quotes for terms they didn't like, they might be accused of being complicit in the "woke mind virus" that has stupid people so terrified.
12Looks like some gave you a good explanation. For the record, it didn't seem like you posted it in bad faith, just that the writer clearly had an agenda. You probably can't find any other articles mentioning it because it really isn't much of a story, even though it is cool. The right wing is just trying to rile up their base
9
Permanently Deleted
24I agree with you. I think it's a good thing to do to understand the world and yourself better. And for someone such a writing task can sound strange, useless or offensive, but I think it's a good one. I also need to write on different topics, and it helps me to learn new things and understand the world better. Sometimes I use https://essays.edubirdie.com/write-my-essay because for some papers it's very hard to find information, and the time is limited. But if I had such a task, I'd have been very interested in doing some research and writing about it.
1
So we're just posting Fox News articles on Beehaw now, huh?
8The article is terrible, but OP clarified that English is not their first language and they did not catch the BS it conveyed.
3I feel like that's not a good reason to leave it up.
4
I think this is the perfect kind of class for undergraduates attending American Universities. A class which directly challenges students' pre-existing biases and lays out contemporary arguments so that the class can have a shared understanding of what they're discussing whether they are supportive or opposed to those arguments. I was challenged like this when I was in college outside of class and having to directly consider these ideas among people I really repected helped me immensely in my understanding of American culture dynamics and ability to use reason when facing difficult claims.
8I navigate my "whiteness" by covering it in clothes... then getting treated dismissively by doctors because I "have plenty of resources", "have your family help you", "just change your whole life or you'll be dead in 5 years", and "have you already stopped with those silly ideas?".
Thanks for the privilege, by the way.
4Permanently Deleted
17It's not just being oppressed in different ways (I've got my dose of xenophobia, fatphobia and ableism), but getting oppressed because of being "too privileged". It's no longer a privilege when you get it thrown at you at every step, when no matter who, they use this or that of your "privileges" to put you down.
And ironically, racism is also a problem for white people, but because some people seem to assume that being white means you must be racist, so they discriminate you for that.
As for doctors, I forgot about the neurologist who kept repeating "It's all in your head" and dismissed me by saying I should get some therapy. When I complained to my GP, she pulled up my history, and it turned out he wrote that he examined me and found nothing wrong. If by "examined" he meant that he saw me sit in front of him while he kept insulting me, then sure.
I've also been told several times that I "have many resources", which seems to be code for "you're so privileged already, you don't need anything".
1
I'm healthy, fit, educated, and kinda rich. I'm also a man.
Do you believe those circumstances grant me with privilege?
The answer is obviously yes, so I'll acknowledge it, rather than try to change the subject to ways in which I'm not privileged. Bringing up ways that white people may not be so privileged doesn't actually address whiteness as privilege.
And privilege isn't even something to feel guilty about. It's just worth acknowledging in a "know thyself" kind of way.
12Bringing up ways that white people may not be so privileged doesn't actually address whiteness as privilege.
What about ways in which "being privileged", turns out to actually be a hindrance?
I used to be a healthy, fit, educated, not poor, not homeless, white, tall, man, blonde, with blue eyes... oh, and high IQ.
Wait, did I just describe the Aryan ideal? Ultra-privileged, right?
What pisses me off, is that after being aware of those privileges from relatively early, and being really careful to never abuse any of them, when it turns out that I need help, instead I get my privileges thrown in my face.
It's not a privilege to get mocked and laughed off by doctors, to get failed by teachers, to get your work destroyed, to not get believed about family problems, all because "you're privileged".
Heck, I once almost got run over by a car, because I nodded at a black girl to let her pass first, and she went off her way to hit me with the stroller with her baby inside, pushing me off the curb into traffic. Like, seriously?
So what, did I live my life wrong? Should have joined some neo-Nazi group? Should have used my privileges to abuse and scam everyone left and right? Should have kicked the baby...? The fuck.
1