Alternative to Google's "Messages" app (for SMS) on Android?
https:// play-lh.googleusercontent.com /9AZOTXU_CpreTFAXUPAmJNkm8VGCb1C90fjJ9pHGcVmpGMDSTq3cUbaQJdBT9Tdp9A=w480-h960 Alternative to Google's "Messages" app (for SMS) on Android?
Does anyone know of an open-source alternative to Google's "Messages" app, which takes care of SMS/text messages on my phone?
I was looking for open-source alternatives on PlayStore and F-Droid but can't really find anything – most apps seem to target some extra purpose than simply handling SMSs.
(Edit: I'd like to stay away from the "Simple Mobile Tools" line because I don't know if it's open source, and I don't like the way they promoted some apps – forcing users to update to pro and similar.)
Cheers!
QKSMS all the way, you can schedule messages, block, archive, create back up, change colors. No ads.
30PSA: QKsms has been crashing for me a lot on CalyxOS. Crashes when I try to change group chat title or when trying to unschedule a message (terrifying). Installing the previous version fixed it for me.
1
I personnaly use QKSMS. It's available on F-Droid and it's quite nice
20Not Op, but thanks for the recommendation. I've got chomp right now. It's all right, but I don't really love it
2
I used to use all the Simple tools, even paid for them, unfortunately the dev changed monetization to a shitty model and I got locked out.
Since then I moved to QKSMS. Its on F-Droid and despite some initial quirks I'm very happy with it.
12@youngerpants@lemmy.world @0_0@lemmy.world @InterSynth@lemmy.dbzer0.com @poudlardo@jlai.lu – thank you for QKSMS, it sounds good. Strange because it doesn't appear with an "SMS" search on F-Droid – but now I got the link :)
Note: I read some users recently complaining about it missing some SMS; let's see if that's still a problem.
4The play store version is out of date (version 3.9.2, last updated 2021-02-07).
You should get it from F-Droid or Github (version 3.10.1, last updated 2023-01-16/2023-01-19).
Edit: Apparently it was only a small update and it's still practically abandoned.
4
The SMS app from Simple tools is bad anyways. Group messaging is totally messed up. I threw in the towel when i responded to a group message and it sent an individual message to each person in the group.
1You can fix that in settings (and I did), but it's still wild that the default setting for group texts isnt MMS. What I've found even more frustrating is that there seems to be no way to make it show you a name on the contacts in a group chat. It only shows the first letter and a random color for each individual person. Can be tough to figure out who's who even amoung my closest friends just because half their names start with the same letters.
1
I'm also interested in this since Signal stopped supporting sms for being unsecure...
11I wonder if any of these listed alternatives support RCS, SMS/MMS is an incredibly old and insecure
8RCS is proprietary. Very unlikely there will ever be an implementation that is open source or foundation driven.
8I honestly don't like RCS, because when I send an SMS, I want it to be using that old protocol that doesn't depend on network functionality. Whereas any real chatting I usually take using more secure apps. SMS for me is "hey, you're not responding on our normal chat programs, is your wifi dead or you roaming?" kind of situation.
7Agree about the security. I don't use SMS regularly, but some people message me with that in emergency situations, for instance if they don't have wifi or data. It's also still used to get temporary authentication codes.
2
I'm using QKSMS from F Droid. Last version is from January of this year.
7Simple SMS Messanger by SimpleMobileApps: https://www.f-droid.org/packages/com.simplemobiletools.smsmessenger/
7QKSMS is the only currently viable open source choice.
6Permanently Deleted
5Cheers, I'll check that too.
1
- 4
Had not heard of Silence, Cheers!
2I'd say Silence is abandoned, it hasn't been updated in 4 years.
2It's really annoying they haven't made an RCS API public. Do you know if they've made any statement as to why?
1
4Capitalism
3Permanently Deleted
1
Silence hasn't been updated for 4 years. Don't touch it.
1
Simple mobile tools pro version are completely open-source and avaliable for free on fdroid. But of course I also paid on google play to support the developer, then use everything on f-droid.
4I'm all for supporting developers. Usually I test an app for a month, and if it works well, I make a regular donation (else I uninstall it).
However, while trying out the free version of "Simple Gallery" from Simple Mobile Tools, they sent an update that suddenly made it only last for 14 days, then you had to upgrade to premium. I simply don't like this kind of behaviour, that's why I don't use their products.
6That is really disappointing. Although it is perfectly fine for developer to ask for money, especially for FOSS app. It seems like their communication is not exactly on point.
I guess the best course of action is to try on fdroid, if you like it buy on Gplay (or just donate if it not terribly inconvenient), and continue to use the fdroid version.
2
You won't be able to use RCS without Google messages
3Looks like QKSMS is not maintained for ~2 years
3About that, see comment by @Anafabula@discuss.tchncs.de in this thread. Apparently only the GPlay version is unmaintained.
2I used to use QKSMS, the only update that has been pushed in the last two years was a very small change in January '23 that corrected an error handling of question marks and fixing a start up crash. It is functionally unmaintained at this point.
The developer has ghosted the project in past years as well, dropped out for over a year but eventually did come back. It's never been this long of an absence though.
3Hmm, latest commit in it's github repository is from 2021
2
??? You have a couple on F-Droid that does what it's supposed to. But in general, should avoid using SMS if you are intending to be privy.
1Permanently Deleted
1isn't signal dropping sms support?
9Permanently Deleted
-5
Dump SMS and switch to an app like Signal. Signal offers end to end encryption and features like disappearing messages. As easy to use as any SMS app.
0Agree about the security. I use Element/Matrix. I don’t use SMS regularly, but some people message me with that in emergency situations, for instance if they don’t have wifi or mobile data. It’s also still used to get temporary authentication codes.
5