Anyway, I'm trying to understand this whole power consumption thing too. See my other post if you're interested. And my conclusion is that it just doesn't make sense. There are a lot of factors involved. Nuanced things, like quality and of components, firmware etc. You can't just say old == bad power consumption, new == good consumption. Your 2012 server is a good example of that.
In my opinion, the best thing to do is just look up the specific model you intend to get and check what people's experiences are for that particular model. And there is your expected power consumption.
Out of curiosity, what's your desktop setup? Particularly motherboard, CPU, RAM, PSU model and capacity? 30W idle without a GPU is exceptionally good for a 6 year old PC.
Thanks for your comment!
This is the kind of info I was looking for.
I’m not only looking to find out how to reduce the consumption of this specific machine (although that is a goal too), but want to better understand what hidden factors affect power consumption. Why can seemingly similar machines have very different power characteristics.
Based on your comment, some of the hidden factors that I wasn’t aware of may be:
- CPU cores. More cores might draw more at idle regardless of max TDP.
- Chipset, memory controllers, and PCIe lanes.
- Notes: I have just checked the chipset on Intel’s website, and it says TDP is 7W. I’m not sure whether it is indicative of the total power draw a motherboard with said chipset. There may be other stuff on the board, even if we don’t count the integrated peripherals, like an Ethernet card.
- PSU efficiency, especially at low loads.
- Notes: If I want a low power system, I should use a PSU with a low power rating and high efficiency. The Z440 came with either a 700W or a 550W PSU. I don’t know which one mine has at the moment.
- Would be interesting to test the system with an efficient, 200-400 W PSU…
- BIOS settings that affect the CPU’s behaviour and low power modes.
- Note, idea: There might be other differences in how different motherboards and different BIOS’s handle other system components in terms of their power saving modes. PCIe lanes, USB slots, and pretty much everything has power saving modes nowadays.
- Memory voltage and speed.
- GPU power saving states.
Thanks again for your comment. These are great ideas. I can imagine these can add up too and make a big difference when combined.
Edit: A better title would be: What makes certain machines much more power-efficient than others?
I have the above machine, and the idle power consumption is too high to my liking.
Full specs:
- HP Z440 workstation
- Intel C612 chipset
- Xeon E5-1650V3 CPU (Haswell)
- 32 GB RAM (4 x 8 GB modules), ECC of course.
- 512 GB SSD
- Nvidia Geforce GT 710, 1 GB
- 2 fans: 1 x CPU + 1 x case. (+ one more in the PSU)
That’s it, nothing else.
It draws about 100-110 W idle. I find this a bit too much.
I understand this is a 140 W TDP CPU, but when I research this topic, every article and comment say the max TDP for the CPU doesn’t matter. That’s just the indication of the consumption at maximum load. At idle, all CPUs should consume minimal power in theory, regardless of the max TDP. Haswell and Broadwell CPUs should be especially power efficient compared to their Sandy Bridge and Ivy Bridge predecessors.
I’ve also seen a lot of comments that it’s mainly the other components that matter, not the CPU. But I don’t have a lot of components either… The setup is quite minimal.
It’s not just the power consumption that bothers me, but the fact that I don’t understand why! Especially considering that there are examples of servers based on similar or older architecture, consuming as little as 30 W. For example this comment. A server with an Ivy Bridge CPU, E3-1230 v2, idle power consumption 30W. Sure, that CPU is 70 W TDP, not 140 W, but…
But then the saying that “TDP does not matter” can’t be true! It means that the CPU’s TDP does matter, and it matters a lot even when it comes to idle power! End even if it's not true, it still doesn't add up, doesn't explain why my setup has 3-4 times more power draw.
Or the other possibility is that it’s the motherboard. There’s something on the motherboard that servers or other machines don’t have that eats this much power. But what is it?
It just doesn’t add up! The VGA card is about 20W max. I checked. Probably less as it’s not under load. RAM + SSD + fans 20W max, but probably less. And there is nothing else. This means the CPU + motherboard consume at least 60-70 W, but probably more. Why? And what is different in similar machines or servers that consume much less?
This is a very good comment, and answers many of my questions. Thank you for this!
I’m looking at new servers, and I see many of these Gen8 HPE servers have this error for sale. I’ve read somewhere it’s a common problem, many of them are affected.
My question is: For a home server, do I need iLO at all?
I don’t care if I can’t remotely restart the server, or remotely check its health. Apart from remote management, is iLO needed at all?
What will I miss if the server has this error? Is it going to be problematic to have this server in any way, or is it fine?