Skip Navigation
Jump
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | 2x07 "Those Old Scientists"
  • But seriously what does the Koala know can we even handle such knowledge

    3
  • Jump
    Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | 2x07 "Those Old Scientists"
  • An extremely fun episode, had a stupid grin on my face right from the opening.

    One thing that jumped out at me was the adjectives used: "scientists, explorers, adventurers." The episode reinforced what Starfleet as an organization and Trek as a concept are all about.

    19
  • Jump
    Can anyone recommend a NuTrek viewing order? Or does it not really matter?
  • SNW spins out of DIS season 2, so probably watch that before starting SNW.

    Beyond that I wouldn't say there's a strict order, until the recent SNW/LD crossover the rest have been pretty self-contained (almost regrettably so).

    2
  • Jump
    Star Trek: Discovery | Fifth and Final Season - Extended Clip | SDCC 2023
  • but it’s also Star Trek discovery

    This is important; there's a distinct feel to the narrative, cinematography, performances and dialogue that the other series def don't have and kinda maintains through all four (soon to be five) seasons.

    2
  • Jump
    Star Trek: Discovery | Fifth and Final Season - Extended Clip | SDCC 2023
  • Depends on what you disliked about it.

    But imo season 3 is where the series grows it's beard.

    4
  • Jump
    Star Trek: Discovery | Fifth and Final Season - Extended Clip | SDCC 2023
  • My nipples got stiff.

    New (final ;_;) season can't come fast enough.

    0
  • Jump
    Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | 2x06 "Lost In Translation"
  • A Short Trek with them bickering, please.

    10
  • Jump
    Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | 2x06 "Lost In Translation"
  • Their early scenes kind of felt pissy in a way you don’t usually see in star trek.

    I liked them, personally. I often think about what conflict would look like in a post-scarcity people... and sibling resentment, minor grudges (re: Una) feel like the sort of thing that stand the test of time.

    6
  • Jump
    Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | 2x06 "Lost In Translation"
  • That was the only part of the episode I found weird.

    Like congrats a captain that doesn't just leave their ship for every little thing... but not even a lil' interaction with them? Not even a "howdy?"

    2
  • Jump
    Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | 2x06 "Lost In Translation"
  • They sneezed at it wrong... and the shutdown measures malfunctioned.

    And they couldn't very well just let the deuterium-creatures continue being butchered while they sorted it out.

    1
  • Jump
    Are humans below mosquitos and polar bears in the food chain?
  • There’s a pithy saying about science that goes, “All models are wrong, but some models are useful.”

    It reminds me of something a sociology professor said about economic and sociological theories being lenses that focus on particular aspects of the world--they can't see everything, but often they can narrow in on certain parts to aid our understanding.

    6
  • Jump
    Missouri has decided to turn down millions in federal food aid for low-income children
  • ... you're going to wait for someone to self identify?

    "Hey we're the enslavers, we're here to enslave people." That's what you're expecting?

    1
  • Jump
    Missouri has decided to turn down millions in federal food aid for low-income children
  • Let's not forget priming a number of the remaining for inflating the prison population.

    ... which is the same as "forcing the remainder to work" come to think.

    4
  • Jump
    Why people can't handle the truth?
  • Damn, I wish I'd noticed this bit of context before responding.

    4
  • Jump
    Why people can't handle the truth?
  • Because we're emotional creatures first, we default to what's familiar or comfortable. Logic/critical thinking take sustained practice and a lot of effort. There's a study that suggests that many of our conscious choices are simply post-hoc rationalizations for decisions made in the unconscious.

    I absolutely no longer trust anyone that insists they're naturally and perfectly logical, they are unquestionably hiding some fixation or personal opinion which--if challenged--will make them unravel in the worst fashion.

    7
  • Jump
    From a legal/evidence perspective, what is going to happen when it will become impossible to tell the difference between a video generated by AI versus the real thing?
  • I expect that if/when that time comes, we'll see the credibility of video evidence decline.

    Currently at my night job, there is video surveillance of common areas. Because of the skill and tools required in doctoring/deepfaking, there's a pretty large window in which footage could be used should it ever need to be. But when we approach the point at which doctoring/deepfakes become pedestrian or even automated, that window slims dramatically.

    Depending on the speed and ease with which it can be done, we could see legitimate arguments in favor of discounting video evidence as it then becomes less reliable than eyewitness testimony (which is already notoriously unreliable).

    2
  • Jump
    Anakin's "balance"
  • Is your body in balance when there's an equal number of cancerous cells? Is your garden in balance with an equal amount of weeds and crops?

    This question pops up seemingly regularly among fandom hubs, and it never considers that balance in The Force isn't an algebra equation. Even with the Rule of Two limiting their numbers, the Sith steadily fomented corruption, fear and misery in the Galaxy building into all out war and fascist oppression.

    The Jedi's failure to respond had nothing to do with their numbers, but with their rigid adherence to dogma robbing them of the tools necessary to address the threat. Dozens of Jedi had spoken up about the rising corruption and might have been effective in fighting it were the Council not obsessed with protocol, optics and precedent--just letting Anakin access the restricted texts would have made all the difference.

    Sidious was uncommonly powerful, but he didn't collapse the galaxy on his own--a string of Masters before him used a philosophy centered on aggression, deception and abuse. They take power by making things worse for others meaning their presence is a net negative for the Galaxy at large.

    The Sith are a cancer, and you don't leave cancer in a body if you want it to stay healthy.

    1
  • Jump
    Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | 2x05 "Charades"
  • We definitely didn't get enough of his reaction to the human reveal.

    3
  • Jump
    Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | 2x05 "Charades"
  • Poor guy! Imagine being married to someone like his wife…

    Bold of you to assume that her domineering personality isn't exactly what he likes about her.

    2