Stardew Valley dethrones Valve classic Portal 2 as Steam’s top-rated game
Cozy farming sim Stardew Valley has become the top-rated game on Steam, surpassing a Valve classic in the process.
You're viewing a single thread.
Portal is such a great series. I hope we get a new one one day.
I had to settle for Lego Dimensions. Better than nothing. And GLaDOS arguing with HAL 9000 was pretty epic.
Both Portal levels and both Doctor Who levels were great.
It's one of my favorite games of all time, but I don't think Portal 2's basic formula would be culturally relevant if it was reused today. The quippy writing is very 2010s-coded (à la Guardians of the Galaxy), the gameplay is a bit too simple to be re-used as is in 2025, and the sweet&short linear storyline of Portal 2 would ironically be lacking ambition for a successor to Portal 2.
Like all truly Great pieces of classic media, Portal 2 is a product of a skilled and truly passionate team getting together at the perfect time with the right idea, and reaching its public at a culturally relevant time.
The Portal universe still has stories to tell, and there are still test chambers to solve, so I obviously wouldn't complain if Portal 3 came out, but I understand why Valve wouldn't want to make a barely decent game in the shadow of Portal 2.
The Talos Principle became an interesting spin on the idea of FPS puzzles that try to keep you engaged. They got more direct with introducing the lore of the world around each time (P1<TTP1≈P2<TTP2). The puzzles are probably less eye-catching because you rarely shoot yourself into air, they are closer to classic 2d logic timekiller games, but I find these games are what Valve need to look at to see if they want to expand the world like that in their own way. If we assume Portal 3 would be about portals, wouldn't reinvent the formula from the ground up, I think they'd need to go for higher stakes, and seemingly expanding the world or the mission at hand (from the probably sterile conditions of it all affecting just Chel and Apperture's robots and facilities), be it an escape into the outer world of some sort (although it overlaps with Half-Life, is it bad?) or make her herself not the only thing at stake. My only hope is that it won't be AR\VR\whatever experience because it would make me nauseos and\or poor.
(They've already stated they won't do Portal: VR because of the nausea issue.)
I completely agree with your analysis, they would need to completely switch up the ambitions from a writing perspective for Portal 3 to make any sense. There are plenty of super interesting stories to be told in Aperture Labs, but I don't think that Valve is structured to write any of them
Valve has always been "gameplay/tech first, story second", and it just happened that Portal 2 delivered unexpectedly well on the writing. But I don't think they can make a game with gameplay/tech twice as ambitious as Portal 2, and at the same time double down on Portal 2's amazing writing. They're just human and most of the people involved have moved on with their lives; in fact Portal 2 was their last truly ambitious narrative-heavy game, and they had to hire the old writers as consultants to make Alyx (which I haven't played but from what I heard the narrative wasn't on HL2's level).
I'd love to be proved wrong but IMO there won't be a Portal 3 for as long as Valve exists in its current form.
I agree. But hear me out:
Portal 3 explores the fleet of Gaben's megayachts with puzzles to get a control of them and also some abordaging\swimming mini-games to get from one to another, from smaller to bigger, with the last one being the promised Aurora Borealis, where game leaves us on an uncertain moment after we too see the feared G-Man but in Freeman's glasses, got catched by a Smoker's tonque in mall ninja rainbow colouring, only to be freed by Pudge teaming up with Scout.
VALVE TEAM: THE END OF LIFE FOR DEATH FORTRESS: EPISODE FOUR: THE PORTAL TO THE INTERNATIONAL
I'm happy they don't do that and for all I care I can wait if they do something or not as long as I can still play in their classics.
If you like portal you may also like superliminal. It's the only game I've found that scratches the similar itch
For the puzzle part, sure, but not the humor. I like The Stanley Parable for that aspect.
I'd also recommend The Talos Principle and The Turing Test for similar itch scratches.
Thanks for reminding me I have the Talos Principle 2 DLC in my inventory that I have to play!
I still haven't played 2!
In a similar vein to Superluminal, I'd also recommend Viewfinder, it's kinda like Portal but with a camera rather than a Portal gun.
Antichamber is another that feels similar. Although Antichamber doesn't really have a plot.
Ooo I've never heard of this! Kinda sad I only saw this comment after the Summer Sale :P Thanks for sharing!
If that's your kind of game, Unfinished Swan is another thats more plot based, but still has some fun puzzles. Doesn't get mentioned as frequently so usually one people haven't seen/played before.
For anyone that hasn't seen it, Portal: Reloaded is a fan-made dlc that's really quite good as well.