2 wk. ago • 95%

What’s the best concept album?

I just played American Idiot and The Wall from start to finish. For me, both are absolute masterpieces. I wouldn’t be able to say which is better than the other.

What’s the best concept album for you?

37 comments

Queensryche - Operation: Mindcrime, or
Dream Theater - Metropolis, Part 2: Scenes From a Memory

12
- SFaM was my answer. I bought that on CD when it was still newish and it was on repeat for a long long time. And I've listened to it at least twice a year for the last 15 years. (sobs) I'm so old.
  
  If I die tomorrow I'd be alright Because I believe That after we're gone The spirit carries on
  
  4
I tried to limit my picks to one per artist and omitted the only loosely conceptual albums.

Top 3:

The Who - Quadrophenia

Genesis - The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway

(Not UK) Frank Zappa - Joe’s Garage

Other great ones:

Kinks - Lola vs. Powerman and the Moneygoround, Part 1

Marillion - Clutching at Straws

Moody Blues - Days of Future Past

David Bowie - Diamond Dogs

Pink Floyd - it’s impossible to choose just 1

Edit: how could I have forgotten Jeff Wayne’s Musical Version of The War of the Worlds?

11
The Wall is good but I like Animals more. The mood hits a bit harder imo.

7
- Yeah but there's a film of The Wall and all the tracks are different versions, plus Bob Geldof, plus animation by Gerald Scarfe
  
  A genuine work of art
  
  4
  
  Oh for movie night it's gold!
  
  1
Kendrick Lamar - Good Kid, mAAd city

I may not be his biggest fan anymore but this album was incredibly influential for me personally and in my opinion, for the whole genre.

6
Sturgill Simpson - Sound and Fury.

Especially if you watch the anime that was created specifically for it on Netflix. Flat out amazing.

5
- Great suggestion, but I'd actually say The Ballad of Dood and Juanita and Sailor's Guide to Earth are better concept albums from Sturgill Simpson. Although, OP seems to lean toward rock more than bluegrass/country, so Sound and Fury might be a better place to start.
  
  1
Unleash the Archer - Abyss

5
Foreign Skies by The Dreadnoughts

It's a concept album by a folk-punk/cider-punk band about WWI, released for the centennial. True to the punk roots, most of the songs deal with the dark, ugly, and gritty sides of war.

There's "Anna Maria", a metal love/revenge ballad about a sailor losing his beloved brigantine to a U-boat.

"Gavrilo" about the horrific consequences of the murder of Archduke Ferdinand.

"Black Letters", a rather haunting song inspired by the last correspondence that a young Canadian soldier wrote to his wife.

"Back Home in Bristol" tells the story of a young man, afflicted by PTSD, facing court-martial for failing to obey orders due to his condition.

"A Broken World" is a reading of English poet Amy Lowell's "September, 1918", which is both heart-wrenching and blossoming with hope.

It's not all bleak though. There's also an original instrumental piece called "The Amiens Polka". And am original shanty called "The Bay of Suvla", which I feel is an upbeat prequel to The Pogues' "And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda".

To top it off, they saved songs that didn't make the cut and released a B sides album as well.

In my opinion, this album does such a great job of striking the emotions that it makes "The Wall" and any of the other "greats" seem vapid and mediocre.

4
- Foreign Skies by The Dreadnoughts
  
  Mmm. Just had a listen. I thought it was ok but not a challenger to the "greats". Certainly not musically.
  
  But that's ok, different people like different things.
  
  2
  
  But that's ok, different people like different things.
  
  <3 That's very fair.
  
  I personally find most of the "greats" to be significantly overrated. They were incredible for their time as a departure from what preceded them but, over-produced and lacking in genuine-ness. They may have had higher levels of instrumental virtuosity but lack relatability, depth, and exploration of the human condition.
  
  To be fair, there's a lot of people who don't want any of that. Many people want escapism, heavy bass with questionable lyrics, or something weird and fun to trip balls to at a laser show. That's fine. I don't care for out of touch celebrity musicians; I want something "real" that evokes emotions across the spectrum and unafraid to dwelling in unpleasant places when the subject matter calls for it.
  
  1
Not the best, but Joe's Garage by Frank Zappa is one of the oddest

4
If you're into indie rock, I highly recommend Separation Sunday by The Hold Steady and The Monitor by Titus Andronicus.

They're both very high-brow (or pretentious, depending on who you ask), but for my money the musicianship and the lyrics just keep me coming back.

Separation Sunday is all about growing up and doing sketchy stuff, finding/losing the faith you grew up with, and finding/losing friends to death, jail, and life.

The Monitor uses the story of an ironclad from the American Civil War as a metaphor for the internal struggle of a 19yo trying to leave his blue-collar roots behind and go to an Ivy League school. If you've ever felt that internal divide between who you are and who you want to be, it's a fantastic album. Shades of Bruce Springsteen with some modern punk.

Speaking of Springsteen, Born to Run could be considered a concept album and it's a classic, especially if you've ever felt the bone-deep need to get away from everything about your home town.

There are a lot of other great suggestions in this thread (especially Good Kid, MAAD City), but they're mostly the standard "best 50 concept albums of all time" that you see in lots of music journalism, so I wanted to make sure my favorites got seen, too.

3
Boys Night Out - Trainwreck

2
Act II: The Father of Death, by The Protomen.

The story, the music, it all works for me.

2
- Fantastic album, would love to see them live at some point
  
  2
A Wake In Providence -- I Write To You, My Darling Decay

2
Mount Eerie - A Crow Looked at Me

It's an absolutely amazing album but also the most tragically sad work I've ever engaged with in any medium. I've only listened to it once because it turned me into a complete mess. I don't know whether I'll ever hear it again.

Mount Eerie is Phil Elverum and A Crow Looked at Me chronicles the illness, death and grieving for his wife, artist and musician Geneviève Castrée. She was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer four months after the birth of their daughter and passed a year later.

It's filled with large and small observations, like the fact that there's no deeper meaning to Castrée's death and describing the things she did for their daughter before her passing, like buying her a backpack she knew she would never live to see her use.

It is a brutally tough listen.

2
That is a really, really good pair.

21st Century Breakdown also does a good job, it's a little different but it's got the same album story.

Deltron 3030 is a stellar album about an intergalactic rapper. It's produced by Del tha Funkee Homosapien and Dan the Automator, seriously, killer.

And before the Flobots came, there was Johnny 5 and Yak who made Onomatopoeia, another stellar album. It's an underground 2000's set though, so it gets gritty. But it's very real and so well composed. That of course led to Flobots Fight with Tools, which may just be the best political album of all time.

2
Chill Out by the motherfuckin' KLF

2
The Kinks are The Village Green Preservation Society. (Also the first concept album if I remember correctly).

2
My favorite is Get Equipped by The Megas. It's the soundtrack of Mega Man 2 turned into a rock opera.

2
666 by Aphrodite's Child is pretty awesome.

It's a concept album based on the Book of Revelation. This is also the band that Vangelis was in before he started scoring movies.

2
Time by ELO

2
Deltron 3030
and
Johnny Socko - Full Trucker Effect

1
Kate Bush - The Ninth Wave
Roger Waters - Amused to Death

1
- I've always preferred Radio: K.A.O.S. even if the concept of hacking nuclear bombs with a cordless phone is… really fucking dumb.
  
  1
  
  ...i adore radio KAOS but its aesthetic sensibilities are definitely an acquired taste...
  
  2
Ooh, 'best' is hard. I think I'd have to go with Operation Mindcrime by Queensrÿche because I only ever want to listen to it as a complete album, start to finish.

Runners up:

Dark Side of the Moon - Pink Floyd

Seventh Son of a Seventh Son - Iron Maiden

Misplaced Childhood - Marillion

The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars - David Bowie

Elizium - Fields of the Nephilim

and, if it counts, Murder Ballads - Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
1
- Came here to suggest Operation Mindcrime as well.
  
  3
My favorite is Queensrÿche's Operation: Mindcrime. It gets pretty regular listenings still.

1
Ayreon’s early stuff is great. The Final Experiment, Into the Electric Castle, and The Universal Migrator (pt I and II).

Kamelot’s back to back albums Epica and The Black Halo are top of my list though.

1
Not best of all time but check out Rock Hole's symphony of aquatic vengeance EP, it's a story that takes place across the 4 songs

This is song 3 of 4 but it's my favorite, the other 3 are uploaded by the same user, they're really best listened to in order

https://youtu.be/Q35D1k-pTtE?si=lsXiyR_frJGOTYHD

1
Hemispheres (the first side is one long concept piece, but the flip side is awesome too) - Rush

1
The Downward Spiral, if you ask me.

1
Kendrick Lamar - Good kid M.A.A.D. city

I've listened to most of the other concept albums mentioned in this thread, but I believe deep in my heart of hearts, this album has the strongest story and emotional impact.

1
I really like the album Hospice by The Antlers. It's about a hospice worker who falls in love with one of the patients

1

You've viewed 37 comments.