My family lost our minds when Pelia (2X03) described the Federation as a...
My family lost our minds when Pelia (2X03) described the Federation as a...
spoiler
moneyless socialist utopia
I mean, we all know that's what it is, but I'm pretty sure that's the first time they've said it straight out in universe. And then the plot reminds of it several times as that very thing is put in danger.
there were a couple of times on DS9 when Quark and Nog flippantly refer to the Federation in similar terms, but they’re quick, throwaway lines and easy to miss.
18Permanently Deleted
6
Ngl it was kinda satisfying.
14What did they just imagine cash transactions happening on starships even when they said many times in every franchise that they have evolved past the need for money?
6Theres been several times in TOS where people referred to Federation Credits or when Scotty said he "brought a boat". I think most of us were under the impression that it didn't go full post scarcity socialist until the replicators were invented.
5Scotty said he “brought a boat”
It might just be a figure of speech, like Jake Sisko "selling" his first book.
5
Permanently Deleted
4Permanently Deleted
6I will argue that the Disco bit is more intended to add some subtext that outlines Admiral Vance's thoughts than just "haha we eat poop."
I read it as tiredness on Vance's part-- a sort of signal that yes, in some ways the quality of life under the Emerald Chain is better than the sterile closed environment of the UFP's remnant. Contrast this with Osyraa's statement about how she has real apples. He chooses the Federation's integrity when it comes down to it, but he was genuinely considering throwing the Federation's legitimacy behind the Chain.
2
@Reva @OsakaWilson If there's war, there are refugees. If there are refugees there are wealth discrepancies. If there are wealth discrepancies there will be commerce (under the table or over). If there is commerce there will be money. Seems pretty unavoidable. The Galaxy can be a utopia or it can have war, but it can't have both. Star Trek has war, therefore... :)
3@Reva @OsakaWilson “post scarcity”
3Permanently Deleted
1
I was more irked that she said the Federation did good throughout the Galaxy. The Federation has always been limited to this Quadrant. Romulans to the left of me, Klingons to the right. The entire premise of Voyager and DS9 was a wormhole to other parts of this galaxy, neither of which have taken place yet. Even the Borg have not spread to other Galaxies yet that I know of.
1