No sex. No dating. No marriage. No children. Interest grows in 4B movement to swear off men

www.pbs.org No sex. No dating. No marriage. No children. Interest grows in 4B movement to swear off men

In the days after Donald Trump was elected president, a South Korean feminist movement is capturing young women’s interest on social media.

News @lemmy.world

www.pbs.org /newshour/politics/no-sex-no-dating-no-marriage-no-children-interest-grows-in-4b-movement-to-swear-off-men

566 211

您正在查看单个线程.

306 留言

Opposition to transgender rights movements
The 4B movement predominantly sees transgender rights movements as incompatible with feminism.[10] Developing out of transgender-exclusionary radical feminism (T.E.R.F.), the movement holds to gender-critical views on sex and gender,[10] supporting gender essentialism and the exclusion of transgender women from feminist spaces.[12][14] Advocates of 4B are opposed to what they call "gender ideology" (젠더론x) and promote excluding transgender women from feminist spaces, as well as romantic or sexual relationships with them (트젠 안사요).[10] In South Korea, members of the 4B have created gatherings exclusively for what they call "biological females" and "real women".[10]
yikes
- The changelog shows that this section has been added sometime between Oct 30 (last version before Nov) and today. Some possibilities:
  disinformation to discourage the movement. I find this most likely given that "Trans" did not appear anywhere in the original article until this was politicized in the US. The updates between versions inserted anti-trans language in multiple places throughout the article.
  Or, if this is actually part of the SK movement, then I have not heard anything TERF related for the US movement. The US movement probably should rename or otherwise distinguish itself from that.
  Either way, I do not think this should be a point to discredit the movement. It at minimum does not seem related to the US movement and IMO is likely some clever FUD attempt to undermine the movement before it gets traction.
  
  Also none of the sources linked there mention anything about trans women.
  
  Just be aware that people might be into 4B for the purpose of man-hating. A lot of times man-hating extends to transphobia.
  The ideological basis is strong.
- Ffs, you can do 4b without being transphobic.
  Just because some 4b assholes with a website have written a transphobic clause in their manifesto, doesn't mean they speak for all 4b followers.
  Stop shitting all over this movement because you've found somebody in it with an awful take on an unrelated matter.
  Not having sex or relationships with folk who can impregnate you is sensible when your country is about to ban abortion and restrict contraceptive access.
  
  I had not heard of this movement before today. Forgive me if my first instinct is to read their Wikipedia, and be off-put by various descriptions of transphobic stances. I agree with the stated goals, and @nimble@lemmy.blahaj.zone pointed out that the article might have been manipulated to paint them in a bad light.
  If that's the case, then I hope the article gets corrected with proper sources soon, and I apologize for the misunderstanding. But I don't like that you're insinuating that trans issues, and transphobia in particular, are unrelated to feminism.
  I wish everyone earnestly resisting attempts to limit bodily autonomy strength and success in their endeavors.
  
  I'm not saying trans rights are unrelated to feminism.
  I'm saying that transphobic rhetoric has been shoehorned into this cause and has nothing to do with abstaining from PiV sex for the safety and respect of ovulating people.
  Also you may not be aware of how conservative South Korea is. There probably are more than a few transphobic 4b South Koreans as feminism as a movement is still newer there.
  In 'western' countries, radical feminism (with all its flaws) was an integral part of the cultural/philosophical journey into the 3rd wave and intersectional feminism as we know it today.
  It would be really nice if the gender critical terf bullshit could be skipped when other cultures journey into exploring feminism, but as conservative culture by definition has such deeply ingrained bigotry towards minorities, it might sadly just be inevitable.
  
  I mean, we kind of act like the worst men speak for the entire gender. These people can choose to be 4B
  And I am saying this as someone who thinks if the entire male population of the US dropped dead on Nov 4 the world would be a better place.
- The 4B movement predominantly sees transgender rights movements as incompatible with feminism
  Interesting, that his since been deleted from the Wikipedia article.
  
  Really? I still see it, under "Beliefs"
- Women hate women.
- The American version need not be TERF though. It is not an inherent part of what 4B actually entails and is extraneous to the purpose of 4B.

306 留言