1 yr. ago • 99%

California Lawmakers Unanimously Pass Right to Repair Legislation

www.404media.co California Lawmakers Unanimously Pass Right to Repair Legislation

The bill previously unanimously passed the state Senate, meaning right to repair is very close to passing in America's most populous state.

Summary

The California state assembly has unanimously passed a bill that would require electronics manufacturers to sell repair tools and parts to consumers and to make repair guides available to the general public.
The bill, known as the "Right to Repair" bill, previously passed the state Senate and now has the support of Apple, a longtime opponent of the legislation.
If the bill is signed into law by Gov. Gavin Newsom, it would be a victory not just for Californians but for consumers everywhere.
California would become the third state to pass right to repair legislation for consumer electronics, after New York and Minnesota passed laws earlier this year.
The bill is seen as a victory for consumers and environmentalists, who argue that it will allow people to repair their own devices and reduce electronic waste.

Additional Details

The bill was supported by a coalition of consumer groups, environmentalists, and small business owners.
The bill's supporters argued that it would be better for the environments and save them money on repairs.
Apple supported bills after having spent millions of dollars against it.

34 comments

I’m really interested in why apple was so much against it before but are for it now. Maybe there’s an obvious reason, maybe not.

But I’m too tired to google this and dive further in.

60
- It’s actually a very soft bill, it has no requirements to make hardware that is actually pro-consumer.
  
  67
  
  Which is likely why they switched to supporting it. It was this or more strict requirements in the future.
  
  41
  
  Apple won't be forced to change their current business practice if soldering everything to the logic board, security chips disabling devices after repairs unless unlocked with their proprietary software, etc, so it won't affect their monopolizing of the Apple repair market. They'll just have to offer logic boards for sale with a one pg PDF showing how to replace the board, and maybe they'll make the security software fix more available (which would still be huge). But 99% of their users likely wouldn't do it themselves anyway.
  
  Either way, this is still a huge step in the right direction though!
  
  3
- When I worked at Apple, much of the repairing wasn't modular. Simply device replacement at a high fixed cost. They'd then cannibalize the surrendered devices for parts or repair them cheap, then make them replacement devices for the next person to come in. It made huge money.
  
  19
- Apple was against it because if you have parts, you can build counterfit iPhones and stuff (read about that rationale years ago, take it with a grain of salt). Also, the repair market is quite lucrative forcing customers to buy new devices than actually fixing them. They were doing this with iPods way back in the day with irreplaceable batteries or batteries so pricey, "you may as well buy a new one".
  
  No idea why they changed their tune. I could only imagine their revenue streams have leaned more into software now but I'm just an idiot online, what do I know.
  
  1
  
  10
  
  If it's made from all genuine parts from the manufacturer, is it really a counterfeit device?
  
  6
- Try asking Bing. It gives multiple possible answers with references. Still have to check the references anyway because sometimes the references don't support the statements.
  
  -7
Does this mean that the ice cream machines at McDonald's will be working? 😉

Seriously though, this is great news.

35
- iFixit are doing their best!
  
  11
- Permanently Deleted
  
  3
  
  Oh, I know. I was just being silly. But my hope springs eternal.
  
  5
  
  I think I saw somewhere that their machines are always broken because they're locked into a contract with a specific service company that sucks but that might just be McPropoganda
  
  4
Apple probably figured away to make more money this way

34
- Those tools and parts are NOT going to be cheap.
  
  23
  
  Microsoft just started selling spare parts for an xbox controller.
  
  Fixing a drifting thumbstick is 80% the cost of a new controller in parts alone. You can fix it for $5 if you go aftermarket and are happy desoldering over 10 points to remove it.
  
  17
  
  To diagnose the fault you need a MacBook Pro Engineer Edition $10,000, Diagnostic Software $10,000 and Diagnostic Cable $10,000.
  
  Then there's the annual subscription to be able to buy parts , guess how much?
  
  11
  
  So far they aren’t
  
  3
Its probably some watered down right to repair bill and the only reason apple supported it is so they can claim that theres already a rtr bill when someone wants a proper one.

30
- I dunno, even Rossman was for the bill but confounded by apples support.
  
  6
- Precisely this.
  
  5
- Probably going to try to do the same thing to this bill that was done to the NY Right to Repair bill: Gavin Newsom will alter the bill slightly just before signing it that leaves a big gaping loophole for companies like Apple.
  
  5
Does the bill have any provision mandating that parts and repairs be fairly priced (with some reasonable legal definition for "fairly")? Or is apple going to charge $2000 for a replacement iphone screen part?

24
- There might be:
  
  The bill would define the following terms: “documentation,” “electronic or appliance product,” “product,” “fair and reasonable terms,” “service dealer,” and “trade secret.”
  
  https://californiaglobe.com/articles/sb-244-right-to-repair/
  
  11
That's great

5
It's just good business.

4

You've viewed 34 comments.