They probably use a simple posts-over-time equation to gauge popularity, so a 5-second-old community with 1 post technically has a rate of 12 posts a minute. Very popular.
This is the one that gets me. If I'm doom scrolling a community and accidentally comment on a 3yr old post, it shouldn't get catapulted into hot. Hot should be filtering out anything older than 2 days
Ah, the YouTube experience. Jeez, you guys are still talking about this? Wait, no, no you're not.
Reddit was getting pretty bad about surfacing ancient threads there, for a while. I thought they were back on their bullshit about Gamestop but no, three year old thread.
Considering I've enjoyed some of the "old" videos the algorithm sometimes sends my way, I'm not always disappointed when I find one I hadn't seen before.
I haven't dug into the docs so I'm not sure if this is a feature or a bug, but I've noticed that old posts will never get pulled into my instance after I subscribe. So a sub can appear empty, but then I'll click to go to its home instance and it's full of posts. Lemmy only syncs new posts upon federation (but again, not sure if that's intended/expected).
This is the biggest usability problem for me on Lemmy right now. I don't want to hop between instances.
Hot sorting normally has some weight put towards new posts so they show up occasionally. I think on lemmy right now the weight of new posts is just way too high.
I tend to stick to top in time period, and use hot as a smarter version of sort by new.
you're not wrong.. but because its completely dead.. Its up to end users to use it more. Users should start commenting more than you did when you were on reddit.
Experiencing the other side of this having just built a new instance. As the communities get closer to 50 subscribers, all I can think is "post, post, post"