11 mo. ago • 96%

Threads accounts will be available on Mastodon and other services that use the ActivityPub protocol.

https://www.threads.net/@zuck/post/C0zXcQmxO77

41 comments

Let's not, okay? I don't want corpo shit in my free fediverse.

45
- So join an instance which shares that opinion...
  
  33
- No, only the people I like are allowed to play on this public playground....
  
  But it won't matter once Lemmy brings in instance blocking for users.
  
  12
  
  It's an existing feature of Kbin and it;s quite cool
  
  3
- @DmMacniel Just be on instance that is defederated from them, done
  
  @fossilesque
  
  6
  
  That doesn't actually fix the issue. If Facebook is trying to set itself up like Chrome with the webplatform, or GTalk with XMPP, then they will drive the feature set of ActivityPub, whether you're federated with them or not.
  
  Hypothetical example:
  
  Want to see this picture/video from someone on Threads? You need Facebook's proprietary picture format, which has DRM baked in it. Even if you don't federate, Mastodon, Lemmy, etc now have to take energy away from their work to adopt the proprietary picture format. It depends on the proportion Threads takes on the network and how they can leverage that position to put pressure.
  
  Threads currently has voice notes. Should all ActivityPub services support that? If so, do we adhere to Threads' standard or not?
  
  6
no thank you

29
24
- Not more than it is now. Everything is already public so if they need it, they've already been collecting it. This doesn't really change anything.
  
  51
  
  And it's how federation is supposed to work. Either you want to send your content to other instances or you don't. But federation is the wrong tool if you want to stay alone. You can defederate and block them if you don't like their terms.
  
  16
- It aleady has been. Anything, anything publicly posted and available will be harvested by, at a minimum, Google spiders. The only privacy benefits of any site can only be promises that they won't share the information that you don't publicly list.
  
  And even then,.all it takes is the feds raiding a dipshit Kolektiva admin to get that information illegally anyways.
  
  Do not organize serious actions over social media. At most, hold sensitive discussions over private, E2E encrypted chats like Matrix.
  
  9
- Honestly. This is a social network platform. Assume all you post and share is being collected via web crawlers and data brokers pulling from the api.
  
  7
- Yeah, it has been the major issue with this. Corporate evil is the worst kind of evil because it acts like a mould. Regardless of what it says now, once they taste that free resource, it will be integrated into whatever else they do. They are gluttons.
  
  3
Oh, fuck. He's optimistic

24
- that general purpose ai model is really coming along, aint it. i hear its got legs now
  
  5
  
  VR
  
  1
I'm all for companies participating in open source communities... but this is the company that routinely blocks me from viewing my aunt's reposts of Russian state sponsored racist propeganda just because I don't install the incredibly invasive mobile app.

I can imagine a few ways that this could go wrong...

22
Will be interesting to see how they deal with nazis and CSAM from all the Japanese servers.

15
- This is just posts on Threads being pushed out to Mastodon.
  
  Still no way to publish to Threads users from outside the walled garden.
  
  17
  
  Yeah will be interesting to see if they enable two-way federation. It's problematic for them
  
  9
- I think even the Fediverse as is, has done an alright job with that.
  
  6
- It’ll fit at home with their users.
  
  4
Anyone know of kbin or Lemmy instances that will insta de-federate from anything meta?

Edit: missed the 'de'

14
- Assuming you meant de-federate, there are a few listed on https://fedipact.online/ that seem to be lemmy instances.
  
  14
- Permanently Deleted
  
  5
- I myself already did. Many big instances also do
  
  5
I'm very curious how this will all shake out. I can understand all of you who want to block Threads and the only two instances that I am on myself are going to do exactly that, but it seems tremendously likely that the flagship instance of the fediverse, mastodon.social, will federate and it will have a massive impact on not just the culture, but also on the codebase. For example I wonder what services will go for feature parity and add features like voice notes which Threads added recently. Oh and culture-wise, with POTUS joining Threads, big institutions like the White House will suddenly appear on the fediverse.

Still holding out hope that a bunch of new users and new ideas will rejuvenate the fediverse, in any case 2024 should be a big year for it.

9
I’m not against Threads joining fedi. That’s where most of the Arabic content is and it is nice that it will be easier to share.

3
I look forward to the additional people Threads could bring here. Once the conversations are both directions I think many people will migrate to this side to avoid ads and Meta.

1
no it won’t. yall dont read.

-9

You've viewed 41 comments.