5 mo. ago • 98%

Which link/bookmark manger do you prefer, and why?

There are so many out there, a few that I came across include:

Wallabag ( GitHub, Website): Older, long history, somewhat clunky now?
LinkWarden (Website): Focus on multi user and teams?
Raindrop.io (Website)
Omnivore (Website)
Hoarder (GitHub)
Shiori (Article)
Readeck (Website)

Having a giant comparison table for this might be nice

40 comments

I use the bookmark manager in Firefox, which I can search through.

17
- Similar here. As I don’t need multi-user support, I don’t bother with self-hosting some tool.
  
  Bookmarks go to Safari where they’re synced between all my Apple devices and pop up automatically in the address bar.
  
  And long-term bookmarks (news articles, references, etc.) go into Anybox which keeps an offline copy of the website so I can still read it in 10-20 years.
  
  8
I've been using Raindrop for about five years. The solo dev really impressed me with his responsiveness to user feedback, so I started paying for premium ($30/yr) even though I don't really need the extra features.

I've used the mobile app, Firefox extension, desktop app (Linux and Windows), and the web app. All have worked flawlessly and have grown more feature rich without ruining the user experience.

The features I use the most are:

Endlessly nestable folders that I can give my own icons to make them significantly easier to navigate around

Public collections so I can save my favorite GIFs and memes on a public page I can refer back to and share

Tagging, descriptions, and notes so I can save a lot of context for each bookmark and why I saved it

The built in preview for the mobile app feels buttery smooth, so I seldom open tabs in my mobile browser when I'm visiting my bookmarks

The main premium features I actually use are the broken link detector to find links that no longer exist and the permanent copies of those pages

I haven't had a chance to use the REST API, but it appears to be documented quite well.

Overall I've had such a pleasant experience that I've never looked at any other option.
11
- +1 for Raindrop, that app is amazing, I keep watching for a self-hosted version/alternative that is as good and they are getting closer. The killer feature for me is being able to highlight stuff and then when you visit the site again you see what you have highlighted (in addition to saving them elsewhere). I also pay for premium because it’s great, I don’t use a ton of the pro features either.
  
  2
- It really is super good
  
  1
Linkding which is like pinboard but self hosted. Just because it’s simple. I could do with just using browser sync but hey, I’ve got a server running so I might as well host it

10
- I love linkding, couldn't live without it.
  
  2
- Linkding is great ! I love it ! With the new local copy as html file thats a banger !!
  
  Except one thing I hate about it... It can get really messy quickly If you don't overthink your tags... This can get time consuming in the long run !
  
  1
Does Floccus count? It syncs via caldev into the native bookmarks.

10
Linkwarden. Because it has a good design, tags, is selfhostable, has some nice integrations (browser-plugin, PWA) and saves backups of the bookmark in PDF.

7
- Linkwarden maintainer here, thanks for the shoutout and stay tuned for exciting updates as we have lots of new features lined up for the next release :)
  
  5
I've been using Omnivore, with Obsidian plugin to have local copies of the pages.

6
- Tell meore about the obsidian plugin, dusbt know of it.
  
  1
  
  Basically you can mirror the instapapered versions of your saved pages as markdown files in your obsidian vault. You can customize the whole thing basically so you can put it wherever and have it tie in to your PKM system however you want. I've got mine organized in weekly folders with a dataview block in my daily note showing the articles I've saved that day.
  
  4
- Tell meore about the obsidian plugin, dusbt know of it.
  
  1
I migrated all my Firefox bookmarks to a self-hosted Linkding instance. https://github.com/sissbruecker/linkding/ Lightweight and once you get a tagging methodology in place its super useful.

4
- Hey :) would you kindly share your tagging methodology? It's the second time I nuke my linkding docker istance, because everytime it gets so messy that I lose sight of my bookmarks ://
  
  Thank you 👐
  
  1
  
  I don't really have a "methodology" per se, I really just focus my tags on the terms I would use if I were to search online for the same thing, or even as a category to keep bookmarks for a specific topic organized. As an example, for all the web resources I may use when playing Star Citizen, I tag those web sites with #starcitizen, for sites that may have given me guidance on doing something on the linux cli, I tag it #linuxcli. I also really don't obsess over the "cleanliness" of the tags and such, but instead just use Linkding as a database that I can search. I'm not sure if this helps, but hopefully it does!
  
  1
Floccus is what I use for bookmarks.

Works across pretty much any browser and on Android (maybe iOS, I'm not sure). I've got it set up on my Synology NAS through webdav, and it's been reliable.

I do also use Linkwarden, but that's more to collect web pages, and not just bookmark them. The archive feature is great, since it doesn't rely on the page still being live to work.

Linkwarden and Floccus are very different, IMO.

4
I really like Readeck, it is very polished and the fact that it copies links content is very useful when saving Medium blog posts (and generally to make sure that I don't lose the content if the linked page is ever removed)

4
- Oh, nice. Saving the link's content is exactly the feature I've been looking for.
  
  1
Firefox; easy to sync, easy to access, easy to search through.

3
- I wish they would finally finish that rewrite in Rust so that it can be properly self-hosted again. The old Python2.7 version is a security nightmare.
  
  3
  
  I just use their servers, it's encrypted anyways and my bookmarks are all public websites, so other than some data on what I like to bookmark there's not much there.
  
  1
I use the one built in Vivaldi. What's the point of an external bookmark manager?

3
- They backup them locally. Did you ever searched for something you know existed and it's gone forever?
  
  1
  
  Browsers also keep the bookmarks locally with an option to sync. You can export/import them too if needed. Sorry, still not seeing an added value of an external bookmark manager.
  
  Unless what you're trying to say is that it backs up the websites themselves locally then... that's at least interesting.
  
  1
Shaarli + stack theme

2
Selfhosted RSS reader Miniflux + Wallabag + KOReader client in KPW4 = 👍

Miniflux to get all my feeds which I can analyze manually throughout the day and send selected snippets to Wallabag for later reading either during lunch or at night using KOReader client in KPW4.

2
- That's a nice workflow :) except for KOReader, I do the same combo Miniflux + wallabage + linkding.
  
  Wallabag + miniflux for articles to read and Linkding for important stuff (mostly github stuff).
  
  What's cool about that workflow it can be automatically send through each other with their API.
  
  2
  
  I also installed Newsboat as an alternative to the web interface https://newsboat.org/releases/2.35/docs/newsboat.html#_miniflux
  
  1
- What is KPW4?
  
  1
  
  Kindle Paperwhite 4
  
  2
Ok, I realize this is c/selfhosted, but I have a question… why not use something like the xBrowserSync extension for this?

Aside of someone could associate the data to me for my list of favorite web places, which has 100 other exposure points. Is there another use case you’re solving?

1
I've started using Hoarder and am enjoying it. I really like the page caching and automatic AI tagging so that I don't have to.

1
I use linkding for bookmarks and readeck for read-it-later

1
- linkding now support offline snapshot and also has a reader mode. What does readeck bring to the table?
  
  2
  
  I prefer to keep the two separate. My linkding is used to dump pages I may revisit someday or not where readeck is stuff I want to definitely revisit.
  
  As far as features go, the big one for me is that Readeck can export to epub. I don't use it a ton, but it's nice to be able to load an article on my ereader.
  
  1
New Lemmy Post: Which link/bookmark manger do you prefer, and why? (https://lemmyverse.link/lemmy.world/post/15904328)
Tagging: #SelfHosted

(Replying in the OP of this thread (NOT THIS BOT!) will appear as a comment in the lemmy discussion.)

I am a FOSS bot. Check my README: https://github.com/db0/lemmy-tagginator/blob/main/README.md

-1

You've viewed 40 comments.