Why are most of the posts here heavily downvoted?

Why would you visit the "conservative" section just to downvote everything? I don't get it.

33 comments

I downvote posts if they're idiotic.
Communities about idiotic ideologies tend to attract idiotic posts.

I'd guess most voting come from people browsing all communities. That's how I found your post.
- @marcos @McLoud This makes sense, #Lemmy leans to the left
- Decent

Because conservatism is a dog whistle for cartoon villainry.

I did a quick scan and the more misleading and fear mongering posts are downvoted, the news type posts seem upvoted.
Maybe be specific in asking which posts you're concerned about getting down votes? Otherwise I'm going with my general answer here.

Everything isn't downvoted. Sort this community by upvotes and you'll see there are a handful that are positive. You can do the same with the people who post here. Go to their history and sort by most positive. All of them have positive comments and posts.
It's the content that's being downvoted. Not the community or the users.

I think it has to do with the fact that most of the activity comes from non-conservatives, but mods have enacted a rule that all posts must be conservative with a pro-conservative bias and conservative source.
This means dissent can only happen in the form of downvotes/comments. IMO it’s a deliberate way of structuring the community to have this exact view to newcomers, anything not conservative is framed as reactionary.
I would much rather an askaconservative-like place where good faith discussions are more prevalent, but alas that is asking too much.
- Yeah, it's deliberate. On the lemmy.world version of this sub, every time I would post a conservative story, another user would post something progressive, and then my post would get buried and no one would ever see it or interact with it. Why post if no one ever sees it?
  I started this sub to get around that, literally so people would see the conservative posts and talk about them. Sometimes you learn something, sometimes it forces you to actually research your position, sometimes you see another slapfight. Much better than nothing.
  If you want to start a sub of your own, just be warned, modding is filled with horrible judgement calls, and until you figure it out, you will fuck it up constantly.
  
  every time I would post a conservative story, another user would post something progressive, and then my post would get buried…
  That’s because it’s an unpopular post. Rather than focus on the visibility of your content, maybe the problem is the content itself?
  Why post if no one ever sees it?
  Considering lemmy consists of forums with posts and comments under those posts, I understand that it seems there is no point in posting if no one ever sees it. But remember:
  anything posted can still be searched
  posts can be indexed by other tools and recorded for posterity
  Also the point of a platform like lemmy is inherently designed to facilitate conversation. If your posts aren’t getting traction it’s because nobody is interested in conversing about the content you posted.
  Again, the problem isn’t the visibility of the content, it’s the content itself.
  I totally understand the desire to have your own space and that’s why I’m trying my hardest to adhere to the rules of the community, and appreciate not getting permabanned yet. But you’ve gotta see all you’ve done is create an echo chamber for content people aren’t actually interested in or aren’t buying. Yes, there are conversations happening in the community off those posts, but the majority of those conversations aren’t productive, generally veer off the posted content and still mostly people who aren’t even conservative or aren’t buying what’s being sold. And now with this root post the effect it has on outsiders is obvious. It’s painting a narrative that isn’t real due to the way the community is structured. That makes new users uninterested in participating.
  In effect this community only really achieves 2 things:
  prevents conservative posts from being buried (because no other types are allowed)
  allows you to have a place where you make the rules.
  Those are two valid reasons for having a community and I’m glad you have a space, but I don’t see how it accomplishes anything besides appease your desire to see your posts stay elevated in thread.
  Maybe rather than being worried about how your posts stack up against others, you should be worried about why so many people disagree with the content you’re posting.
  If I post an article from a pro-conservative site that can be easily disproven as either lies or misinformation, what’s the conversation of value to be had there?
  I appreciate the warning, but I don’t think I’m cut out for it. I just want to make existing places a better place to engage. Unfortunately that comes down to the users more than the mods, or communities themselves, which is the only reason I’m here. I want to have a space to debate differing opinions, but they seem to break down when one party refuses to admit there’s a flaw in their way of thinking.
  
  In what ways or what's considered, "fucking it up" ? Agree with your comment btw
- Why don't you make that community?
  
  I would love to! But I don’t know where to start hahaha

@McLoud I get the impression that this community is mostly left wingers either angrily downvoting posts, angrily downvoting comments, or angrily replying to the right wing/far right articles that get posted here. I kinda get an r/AskTrumpSupporters vibe from this community, with the exception that the right wingers here seem to be markedly more intelligent.
- Did you ever consider the possibility that anger is the appropriate response to certain situations? For example, if someone passed a law that prevented you from receiving medical care, that would warrant anger.
  
  @morphballganon Yes. The thing is, most of the posts her are not about medical care.
  If we go to the community, the posts on the homepage are about:
  A #Muslim terrorist murdering a cop in #Germany: https://lemm.ee/post/33713396
  A man getting exonerated for raping a child after he says it's part of his ethnic culture: https://lemm.ee/post/33546099
  JoeBiden signing an executive order to limit migration into the #USA: https://lemm.ee/post/33589787

Because lemmy is small, so the natural brigading that comes from everyone being able to see all the posts means smaller/unpopular communities will have these natural downvote noise. I see this in monero, linus tech tips, communities all the time. There are people with a axe to grind, and rather then blocking a community they just want to be negative. it brings them joy, so be it.
Lemmy would benefit from community tools, like requiring participation before votes count, or posting karma, etc.
Growing small communities should be a priority for lemmy

Let me ask you the same question. What do you think is the reason in your opinion ? Not starting a fight here, just want to know what you think.

They hate you and want you to die.
- Sadly I kinda think this is true lol no hate on OP, I'm just saying it does feel and look that way
  
  Search your feelings. You know it is true.

33 comments