5d ago

Am I resistant to advertisements, or is it all mirage?

I saw a post about how nerds are resistant to advertising, which is bs imo considering how obsessed many nerds to products. But then, I do not seem to get affected - I usually do not desire to buy a product, and only seek out what to buy when needed.

That is, I feel like adverts do not work on me. Is this an illusion? Or maybe, is it that many adverts are made to appeal to neurotypicals?

39 comments

The greatest trick of advertisements is to convince you that you’re not affected by them.
- heh the greatest trick of the devil was to convince people that he doesn't ex... wait.....
  ads are the.....?
  shhhh don't say it out loud! they'll come after you!
- Tricking Advertisers With Adverts | MIND CONTROL | Derren Brown
Advertising is subversive. How do you pick what to buy when you buy “when needed”. You may be less susceptible to excessive consumerism - no wall of funko pops and anime character figures - but that doesn’t mean you select the products you buy because of some kind of advertising. Whether that’s fake “rating” blogs/websites that “evaluate” products based on who pays them, reading reviews that have been botted, responding to logo design, etc
Advertisements generally work on the people they are targeted to. Most advertisements are not targeted at you.
Off the top of your head, name a VPN company.
- This is the way it works. The brand name gets lodged into your psyche before you're in that market.
  
  How do they account for users like me, though? Or are we so few that they don't care?
  If I see enough adverts for something I mentally add it to a list of things I'll never use.
  For example I use Windscribe, because when I needed a VPN I did some research on what would be best for me, and I automatically disqualified Nordvpn because of how prevalent their ads are. I've never seen a Windscribe advert, but when I looked for the product, there they were.
  You do need some amount of marketing otherwise nobody will know your product exists at all, but forcing ads into people's faces in uncouth ways is scummy (e.g. animated adverts on pages when I'm trying to read the page content, I can't read it until I get rid of the ad, it hard locks my brain's focus), that's where I usually draw the line.
- Wow, someone needs to hire you to explain stuff. I've seen people explain how ads work before, but this is the first time someone made me think "oh shit they're actually working." I mean I thought of Nord VPN even though I use Proton what the hell?
- also the name Raid Shadow Legends have been shoved into people's brain against their will.
- Fortinet, Cisco, Juniper
- Private Internet access and mullvad
- I don't know any VPN company as of now. One of things I think of using but is afraid of the change.
  Heard a lot about Mullvad in Lemmy tho, kudos to their marketing (maybe).
IMO nerds are mostly not resistant, so much as take pains to actively remove ads from their sight (adblockers, pihole etc, avoiding Meta type crap and so forth). Adtech has been awfully refined over the last century and if they're doing it right you don't even know that it's effecting you, so best to avoid.
Ah, but when you go out to buy something you need how do you choose which product of a category to buy?
- Price to 'value', weight/size, performance, reviews, etc.
  How else would you do it?
  
  Most people will do that but within the confinement of "I've used/heard of this brand"
- Whatever’s on sale that day at the grocery store unless it’s store brand toilet paper because I bought like a 48 pack of that once and it was truly awful. Like wiping with pie crust. So in that case I unfortunately go with a brand that advertises but, to their credit, it doesn’t flake apart into shreds just while bring transported from the pantry to the bathroom
  
  Whatever’s on sale that day at the grocery store
  Sales are an aspect of marketing/advertisement.
It maybe work less on you but it probably still work well on you. Advertisement isn't as much about product anymore, it's about brand. A logo seems innofensive but shown enough it become more familiar to you increasing the chance you choose this brand when you buy a product.
Another type of ad is the "cool people do this" kind with the objective to create a need and make you buy a product of this type. Even if you don't choose the brand that advertised it you still enter the market. If you care less about the judgement of other this kind of ad probably work less, if you're desperate for bonds maybe it work better so I don't really know how different it can be among autistics.
In any case my advice would be to not let your guard down, that's exactly what the seller want. Use an adblocker, mute the tv during adds, don't look at the advertising poster when you walk or drive outside. You could even talk about this to your mayor.
- Hmm, you are right. Maybe Linux sold to me well with its catchy logo
Fast food does this to me. Ill be minding my own buisness and bam the intrusive thought comes in "i could go for x right now". X being thr fast good that taste like nothing with sauce on it that makes me feel sick everytime i eat it.
That was not a product of my rational concious. That was a desire i was given to me. I hate it so much.
I mean most of my decisions are heuristical because most dont matter, but compound them together and subvert the simple decision framework we use for most decisions and you can see how advertising works.
As an exercise make a goal to oppose something you dont like about your buying habits and try to adhear to it. Its overwelming sometimes. Almost none of the market is made to be navigated with rational analysis. The information overload on junk terms and barren land scape of facts is aweful.
I relate but I think it’s also because I spite capitalism so much. The more I see something advertised, the more I hate the good/less likely I am to buy it. Also I am very minimalist and buy very little anyway …
I’m Lovin’ It
Now what burger are you thinking of.
- Whataburger
- There are only handful of burger brands which are available nearby after searching, and I go to whichever place that offers good ones.
  
  Yeah, but how do you know which ones are good? Generally well gravitate towards brands we're aware of due to them being "known" to us.
  And if you say you picked based on reviews, then you're just falling for a different form of advertising as most review sites are heavily gamed.
  
  So, seeing the phrase "I'm loving it" did not 8n any manner put a thought of "hamburger" in your head?
If this is the post you're referring to, it was specifically just about dev/software tools, but the post title made it sound more general
It's like with propaganda. It's not only about influencing what you think but also what you think others think.
- I don't think I am immune to propaganda, but how do ads affect what I think others think.
  
  Sadly nobody is immune to it. You may think you are but the propaganda machine has gotten extremely efficient at working and the littlest things you don't realize can over time change your views on specific things without you realizing it.
I'm telling y'all, it's sabotage

39 comments