Fire in the Sky Just no. I couldn't even look at an image of a grey alien for years. Had to look away during the opening credits of X-files because they flashed an image of a grey. I got over it. I actually rewatched it during the pandemic lock-in. It holds up pretty well.
My cousins made me watch John Carpenter's The Thing when I was eight years old. Assholes.
The movie Saturday the 14th also messed me up for a while, what with the Creature from the Black Lagoon getting into someone's bathtub through the drain pipes. It may be silly dreck, but it was a bit much for a five year old.
I was a real scaredy cat as a kid, so for me Terminator and Jurassic Park were the ones I remember giving me nightmares that other people would know. Outside of that weirdly the movie "the edge" with its bear terrified me, I always imagined a bear could just rip through the wall of our home and grab me. Another weird one was The 13th Warrior, there was a particular scene in.a bloody cabin that really upset me, but I dont think the movie was really scary, I was probably just way too young to watch it
Arachnophobia. I one of the ones that claims I acquired a minor version from the film. Took me years to get over it. Of dedicated effort, after I grew up. Even today a sudden sighting can sometimes get a squeak out of me though, annoyingly.
Oh wow, yeah Event Horizon is not a good movie to see in your youth haha. That's intense!
For me, I didn't get to see the whole movie, but I walked into the living room while my parents were watching Hostel and I saw the achilles tendon scene. That imagery still haunts me to this day. Grew up to love horror, though!
Actually not the OP just thought that this community needed some love. That said I do have a very distinct memory of having one of those two for one DVDs with Event Horizon on one side and some fairly tame solar flare-themed PG-13 disaster movie on the other side that I watched ALL the time. Definitely would've been a shock to go from the latter to the former but I don't think I ever did.
Mars Attacks when I was 6. My parents had the brilliant idea to take me to see it at a drive-in, so larger than life screen, and it was the second film, so I think they probably figured I’d fall asleep and they could stay and watch. Nope. Pretty sure I didn’t sleep for weeks.
Poltergeist 2. I must have been 6 or 7 the first time I watched it. The designs and special effects were amazing. This scene in particular fucked me up big time:
I too was a weaker constitution child and had to leave Beetlejuice and Jurassic Park.
I also ended up scared of Leprechaun in a hotel room when I was like 6.
One that sticks out that I've never been able to place, though. I was in another hotel room with my dad and woke up to it. All I remember was a gargoyle or something was killing people and at the end they managed to trap its spirit in a chair and then burned the chair in a fire. I had nightmares about that movie for years after but have never been able to figure out what it was.
Dark Night of the Scarecrow. This was a made for tv movie, but the scene where they kill the guy hiding in the scarecrow freaked me out as a 7 year old. I’ve never rewatched and had to google a synopsis to make sure this was the right movie.
Trilogy of Terror messed me up pretty badly as a kid. I kept my feet off the floor for a week. I just kept jumping around from piece of furniture to piece of furniture.
I saw Event Horizon in my 20s. My bro-in-law and I thought it was just going to be a goofy horror movie that we could laugh at.
The Shining. Watched it when I was under ten years old.
Couldn’t sleep with the lights off for months.
But I agree with OP about on the Event Horizon movie. My experience with that film was great cause I just expected a sci-fi movie. Instead I got a twisted vision of horror that still haunts me to this day.
Last movie that gave me nightmares was Mirrors (2009). I was alredy barely an adult back then.
I woke up in a panic for 2 weeks straight and put on the light to check my mirrors. I recently decided to watch it again. It's pretty underwhelming and random af to me now. Didn't scare me in the slightest (aside from a few cheap jump scares, but I hate them anyway).
El Orfanato. Watched it as part of a foreign language film club at school when I was about 12/13. Over a few weeks we watched some Ghibli, some great Italian films and then this.
Nothing could have prepared me for this film, I'd never watched a horror movie before. I had nightmares for at least a month, and I'd actually be hesitant to watch it even now because it scared me so badl!
Has to be said though, was a great film and it had me choking up at the end.
Don't Be Afraid of the Dark (IMDb), a 1973 made-for-TV movie. I was single digits old and remember watching the living room TV hiding behind the legs of a kitchen chair.
I remember when I was little my big brother was watching it in the living room, I was told not to come out of my room but from the doorway of my room I could see a mirror that reflected the living room TV. I saw the scene of Chucky melting and I was terrified of toys coming to life until I was about 18-19.
I had a defective Tickle Me Elmo that would randomly go off randomly in the night and would terrify me and my twin brother. I remember my first and only instance of sleep paralysis where the Tickle Me Elmo toy came to life, crawled down the shelf he sat on and touched my head just out of sight while talking to me. After that I cried and cried and begged my mom to take all my toys away.