Victory! Ring Announces It Will No Longer Facilitate Police Requests for Footage from Users | EFF
Victory! Ring Announces It Will No Longer Facilitate Police Requests for Footage from Users | EFF
This is a victory in a long fight, not just against blanket police surveillance, but also against a culture in which private, for-profit companies build special tools to allow law enforcement to more easily access companies’ users and their data—all of which ultimately undermine their customers’ tru...
*ring will no longer publicly acknowledge facilitating police requests...
238They're saying they're not gonna just hand it over. Ring is still gonna have to answer subpoenas.
44They could look to argue those, but I'd suspect they just say 'get a warrant' now rather than allowing for the 3rd party records requests, which by all accounts warrants are pretty rubber stamp. From my non-lawyer recollection there's never been a mandate to get a warrant for records in possession of a 3rd party outside of things protected by other laws like banking or HIPPA. So a provider can hand out lists of all your convos, locations, etc if they want. Some do without question, and after a long record of complying with police requests I have a hard time believing Amazon will suddenly change their tune without force. Path of least resistance and all that.
14
Precisely. They're just gonna be much more careful about their continuation in doing so actually getting out again.
2
The police can just purchase the footage instead from Amazon's ad services.
81I fucking hate these doorbell cameras. In my building, my neighbor across the hall has one,so EVERY SINGLE TIME I come and go from my apt im being recorded. And there’s another on the floor below me. So they know where I go in my building. It’s fucked up. I literally have zero privacy on when I’m coming and going from my apartment.
38It's a long shot, but you could have a chat with the building manager and/or landlord and voice these concerns. I don't know if they'll do anything, but you never know.
9Thing is. Good chance your neighbour was probably a victim of crime. A few nights in a row I was making supper and someone was trying to get in my place by trying the handle. My packages also started to go missing and a few years ago someone walked into my apartment while I was trying to wrangle my cat because the fire alarm was going off, pretty sure they wanted to rob my place because they left without saying anything and got freaked out when they saw me still there. It's nice having it because I can see who is at my door Without putting myself in the line of fire, and it deters people from pulling any bullshit while I'm not home.
It's understandable that it's a bit annoying it's pointed right at your door. Mine doesn't face anyone's door. Just the hallway, you could ask your neighbour to install an angled adapter so it's not facing your door. Personally I treat my building hallways like I would treat any public place, and always assume there's a camera somewhere. There's also a very good chance there is CCTV in your building already if it's a larger building.
3Time to carry an umbrella so you can keep yourself off camera.
1
Not even just a technical security standpoint, why would you put a live camera up when someone else legally owns the feed?
I've had discussions and people claim it's no different because other systems can be hacked and you have a phone with a camera that can be remotely accessed, etc.
But those things are illegal, the people using Ring are knowingly putting up a camera where someone else owns the footage. They aren't hacking, they aren't stealing. In fact, they're letting you borrow the footage anytime you check the camera yourself.
56Because people have been trained since the eighties to ignore EULAs and just click "ok".
Most people, have no idea they don't own the video their door bell takes...
Hell I'm fairly tech savvy and I didn't know. (Don't have a camera).
30In a way the sketchy off brand seems like a better idea in that case, at least there's not some monolithic entity holding millions of feeds to ask for access to
10Most likely cost of entry and ease of use. Those are the things most people are going to be concerned with.
10Here's what I recommend: open source camera firmware if possible, local storage of recorded video on an open source system, firewall rules to block access to and from the Internet for all of the above. If you need "cloud" access to your cameras then set up a VPN to get to it behind the firewall.
That's my setup, minus the specifics.
5Because getting the same results is hard or expensive if you wanted to do it yourself.
A security camera is easy. Reasonably secure view from anywhere is difficult. Notification of activity in view of the camera is harder. Internet to front door intercom is moderately difficult.
0
Ok bruh I’m sure they’re gonna be totally transparent about what they do with the data.
21I guarantee you that this is more of a cost cutting measure rather than Amazon being altruistic. They just laid off tons of people, and this is within that same train of thought.
17-
Hey Jeff, we don't have enough staff to answer all these police requests we're getting.
-
Alright, then don't. Put out a press release, and get our Amazon(TM) ministry of truth to put a positive spin on it.
7-
I was very aware of this "sharing" of footage when I bought my camera system and intentionally did not buy ring and other brands because I want to own that video. I went so far as to not connect my system to the internet which gives me less options (i.e. see it on my phone anytime) but sometimes privacy comes with a price.
13Are they still accessable from the local net, preferably with some auth even without the internet feed? That sounds like a pretty ideal thing to me. Recording and motion ssense starting...
Really what I want is a simple cam that can dump a circular buffer to the NAS via a NFS/smb share and local net live view. Seems simple but yet rare.
1Frigate + HASS.
All my cameras are accessed with Frigate, which stores everything on a NAS (400TB...). Since I can mount up a coral.ai I can do object detection and throw away the frames/recordings that have literally nothing going on. HASS fronts the whole UI for myself and my other users(wife/kids). Cameras don't have access to the internet at all... Local access is sufficient to get it into the interfaces that I need it in.
4
I know Eufy has its issues, but I do really like that all my camera footage is stored in my home and not in the cloud.
Their reputation is not good anymore, but I'm just glad all my footage isn't on someone else's computer.
11I thought their reputation was tarnished explicitly due to uploading footage to the cloud despite claims otherwise. How can you be sure it isn't uploading when their words mean nothing?
11The problem was unsecured connections when accessing your footage through their web portal.
They've since fixed the issue, but they inform people that screenshots are held in the cloud for a limited time in order to serve certain types of push notifications.
I may also be trying to cope with the fact that I bought an expensive system before learning about their issues.
11
it'll no longer WHAT
(just kidding, I was aware of this and am happy about the change, thanks for posting)
8Try it with google and see what happens. Aint no way of retrieving that shit once deleted... Source me and my dead neighbor
7[X] Doubt
7The detectives tried getting footage from google after my neighbor was shot on his ride on mower. One of my cameras faces directly at their paddock they were in when shot. No cigar.... At the time i had let my subscription lapse and only had a 3 hour limit to view events before they were deleted. After 3 hours it's all gone bye bye
14
How were cops able to access the video once they were given access. Isn’t that stuff E2EE? Is there a backdoor, or is it not always encrypted?
5What made you think it was E2EE? I dont think any off the shelf camera system offers that
16Ring says they support E2EE. It looks like it’s off by default. Yikes.
https://ring.com/support/articles/mt13j/How-to-Set-Up-Video-End-to-End-Encryption-E2EE
As for other cameras, when I was looking at systems for my house, I saw that Arlo supports it.
HomeKit Secure Video cameras are also another good E2EE solution if you’re in Apple’s ecosystem. I love that HSV can bypass shitty third party apps, and the camera hardware can connect direct to a HomeKit hub, buuut HSV tops out at 1080p.
8
Finally some good news
4Remember that Google not only cooperates with police, they will report users to the police for things their AI finds in that users photos or documents
When they have done that in the past and police investigated the police found no crime was done, but Google deleted their account anyway. They lost their contacts list, their photos, all the spreadsheets and documents in their Google drive, their email account, all their passwords (and the ability to reset those passwords because of the loss of the email account). The guy also used Google for internet and phone, which also went away when Google accused him
If you keep anything important on an online service, keep a backup offline (https://takeout.google.com/ for Google). Use a password manager that isn't under control of a tech giant.
If you back up everything to an online service, choose one that allows you to encrypt your data so they can't use it against you
3