Borderlands 2 is such a good game that one of its DLCs (Tiny Tina's Assault on Dragon Keep) is also one of the best games ever made, in its own right.
Man. 2010-2015 were some STRONG years in gaming. Portal 2 and its DLCs, Borderlands 2 and its DLCs, Skyrim, Shadow of Mordor, Hearthstone, The Last Of Us, Pokemon X & Y...
Edit: this comment appears to have lost its parent, so now it just seems like a non sequitur, but you folks are smart.
I'm only playing 3 because it's the only game in the series I didn't finish. The villains are so god awful and the writing is so cringe that I've had to step away from playing it several times over the years.
The writing is really awful but boy the gameplay is fun. It's certainly the step up from Borderlands 2 that was needed (even though I love BL2 more in every other way)
I agree with this order. TPS is a slog. It is almost entirely comprised of traveling across the map and then traveling back the way you came except everything just respawned. Over and over again.
The 3rd game makes item drops boring. 'Legendary' gear is ludicrously common which makes anything sub-Legendary pointless. There's no excitement when a legendary item drops because they always drop. The story also does not compare with the second, which was awesome, or even the first, which was pretty good.
Borderlands 2 also has a pretty good VR port that I highly recommend.
I have had this game on EGS for I don't even remember how long since they gave it away for free. Never actually played it because my brother, who is the biggest Borderlands fan I know, says it's absolute fucking garbage.
The gameplay is really well done I think. As much as I love 2, the way you move in 3 makes 2 feel old and kinda slow. As long as you play solo it’s really fun, it’s the story that’s utter garbage but everything else is good.
I did an all achivs marathon of 1,2 and 3. 3 was such a damn slog that I couldn't bring myself to play pre sequel. The characters were all given so much extra cringe in an unenjoyable way. Ava and the twins are particularly bad to the point that they make god of war's rebellious phase atreus pleasant. I should have played pre sequel before, but I didn't have it so I went on to 3 and I think I'll be fine never playing a borderlands game again.
From the reviews I've seen (Outside Xbox), that's the most you'll get out of it. It's mostly a nothing burger, "bad" is the best thing you can say about it.
The story and dialogue is really cringe. The worst part is they straight up disrespect old characters, reducing them down into jokes. Axton and sal come to mind,
But the gameplay and atmosphere are top notch, some really talented people put their souls into the game. I find myself stopping and looking when I find some beautiful scenery, and just having a moment.