well...
well...


well...
When the rich want war it’s the poor who have to die.
The same can be said of Middle Earth.
And Middle Kingdom
And Malcolm in the Middle
What happens if the War in the Middle East ever stops generating obscene profits?
An actual historian can chime in if I'm wrong, but I'm pretty sure the middle east has had some sort of internal or external conflict going on for all of history. So the answer to your question is likely "still war".
I’m pretty sure the middle east has had some sort of internal or external conflict going on for all of history
Prior to the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, the Middle East enjoyed centuries of peace and prosperity. From the 13th to 20th centuries, you were far safer in Damascus or Baghdad or Tehran than Paris or Berlin or Rome. Europe was in a continuous state of civil conflict during this period.
The Middle Eastern states were a popular refuge for European civilians fleeing the 30-Years-War, the Napoleonic Wars, the various wars of consolidation and independence following the collapse of the Austro-Hungarian Empire, and the World Wars. Countries from Morocco to Iran were all common destinations thanks to their unaligned status and divorce from the conflicts in Europe. More common even than the Americas. In fact, a big early appeal of the Palestinian Mandate was that it allowed Christians, Muslims, and Jews alike to escape the pogroms north of the Mediterranean.
In the early years, at the start of the Cold War, a number of the former European colonies broke away from their now-destitute colonial masters. This lead to brief civil struggles, largely centered around the capitals where all those European WW1/2 refugees had piled in. But by and large, the democratization of the Middle East was far more peaceful than the democraticization of Europe.
It wasn't until the 1950s, when spy games between the US and the USSR began to topple unaligned governments, that war in the Middle East became commonplace. But what we're seeing today is a novelty of the 20th/21st century. You're ignoring centuries of peaceful coexistence and fixating on a few ancient (Crusades) and a few very recent (Soviet/Post-Soviet) violent flare ups.
I can't believe this racist bullshit is getting upvoted. Europe has far more of a history of being perpetually at war than the middle east.
Middle eastern history nerd here!
The horror!
World piece peace tour!
Damn that's even better.
Pretty sure it's the rich and powerful who expect to become more rich and more powerful when there is war in the Middle East that bring about war in the Middle East.
Politicians,
If we spend a trillion of taxpayers money to kill brown civilians, it will funnel billions into the pockets of the worst scum on earth, and they will funnel that tax money that could have been used on healthcare, housing, education.. straight into my pockets.
Politicians literally burning taxpayers and human lives in order to get a billionth of that cash.
imagine robbing a bank, by setting it on fire with people inside, only to walk away with 3$ and call it a success.
War... War in the Middle East never changes.
Religion will create all war in the Middle East.
People who don't read history create reductive takes
Except almost all the problems in the middle east today can be traced to the Sykes pico agreement and imperialism by secular powers
Most of the war in the middle east for the past century was created by secular imperialists, motivated by material greed and racism.
interesting, when a nation forms in the middle east without western influence, you get a mutual aid feminist state, which the media does it's best to ignore, because the narrative that it is ethical to bomb arabs must be preserved.
You realize the kurds are heavily backed by the US, Israel and other western powers?
nice job fabricating consent to murder civilians
I'm gassy. I haven't started war in the middle east yet, but I'm young. Ish.
hey, we all grow up at our own time.
no rush,
you'll start your war in the middle east when you're ready.
Oil makes war in the middle east.
What if we all converted to the same religion, mine?
I am interested!
I'm pretty much already part of your religion I just disagree with you on one very minor detail. We are now mortal enemies.
But i like my holy spaghettimonster. It looks tasty and in the afterworld is a beervolcano (where some of believers agree that it gives any drink poeple like)
Too bad, we worship capybaras now and only do what they tell us to do. Now get in the bath and put an orange on your head!
Nothing would change because religion is not the motivation, but the justification.
The Rules of Acquisition? I hate to tell you, but that's kinda what got us into this mess.
OMG, Nostradamus was right!!!
"An empire will rise"
"An empire will fall"
"War will break out in the Middle East"
"The Boston Red Sox will win a World Series"
OMG, was this man a wizard or what?!!
It's called zionism.
People have been slaughtering each other for well over 5000 years in the Middle East.
under that logic people have been slaughtering each other all over the world.
the largest reason of war in the middle east are neocolonialism (western blocks controlling their puppet states for oil) and actually old timey settler colonialism (Zionism).
saying "people have been slaughtering each other for..." is such a non answer.
why did Nazis invade France? because they been fighting in Europe for thousands of years
why was JFK shot? because people have been killing eachother for thousands of years
you see how meaningless, non answer it is?
I bloody hate though terminating clichés.
Yeah with like 300 year gaps of peace per war. Not like this.
Yes, that's about when we got people there.
Sounds like men are the problem.
Counterpoint: Margaret Thatcher
honorary man
That and times
indeed
and
make
I mean have you met men? It's starting to come together in my mind that because of the societal pressure to prevent us from expressing feelings in a healthy manner this is ALL a direct result of it.
I'm a man. Bring on the matriarchy! So long as the matriarchy isn't a bunch of Thatchers!
Edit: oh, hey, cake!
I'm a weak man UwU
strong men create good times (when they meet the weak man)
; )
“Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, weak men create hard times.”
Hard times create strong men, strong men create hard times
Didn't know weak mean makes you hard, but do you have to tell everyone?
Hard men create strong times.
Strong times create hard soft.
Hard soft creates confused hard men.
Confused hard soft create man times.
Hard men create harder men.
Men create man hard soft times for men
who are not soft but actually quite hard.
Hard times create strong men
Strong men create good times
Good times create weak men
Weak man create hard men
Weak men make me hard.
Everyone has their war in the Middle East except the weak men who put it on the Middle East for some reason
for some reason
Because it's true. Strong men don't fight themselves.
"...it's been burning since the world's been turning..."
This isn't dank, it's imperialist meme.
This conflict will never end as long as people keep listening to their imaginary friends over the reality in front of them. And each atrocity on both sides simply guarantees the fighting will last for ages longer.
oh's no's someone's invisible friend told them to downvote these heresies lol
What your saying is ahisotrical because most of the issues in the region since WW1 have been because of western influence and imperialism.
oh you sweet summer child, the crusades mean nothing to you?
not to consider the countless invasions from persia, africa, etc., it's really all that simple huh sparky?
oligarchs are loving your stupidity,
they installed theocratic tyrants to funnel oil, and you blame on the "see, they have a religion different than mine, they so stupid".
and then push their fabricated consent to bomb those countries of their puppets step out of line.
meanwhile, when they make their own nation without western influence, we get the most leftists, feminist state in the world the media is actively ignoring to avoid breaking the narrative.
oligarchs are loving your stupidity,
the mullahs and the rabbis love your naivety.
The vast majority of the war in the middle east for the last century has been caused by secular imperialists motivated by wealth and power.
The standard western refrain of "they're religious, so we have no choice but to carpet bomb their cities, overthrow their governments, and destroy their economies" does not count as religion causing the war. Except maybe for the American Civil Religion, and it's equivalent for western supremacists more generally.
they’re religious, so we have no choice but to carpet bomb their cities
so you assert the christian evangelicals that want to bring on the apocalypse doesn't count as religion causing the war.
mmmmhmmm
The belief in an objective reality is precisely what motivated the crusades, the nakba, and most other genocides. They believed in reality, and they believed their experience of the divine was objectively true for all others. Thus, that their actions were justified.
Peace will only happen when we admit that our perceptions aren't objective. The gods who talk to us in our sleep exist because we believe in them, not because of an external reality. There's no such thing, and admitting subjectivity is the only way to accept differences and make peace.
Now, that's a different angle on viewing these things. Or at least I've never heard it phrased that way. Interesting. Thanks for the insight!
They believed in reality, and they believed their experience of the divine was objectively true for all others. Thus, that their actions were justified.
yeah, I agree they were deranged by deities. fancy way of putting it tho.
Peace will only happen when we admit that our perceptions aren’t objective. The gods who talk to us in our sleep exist because we believe in them, not because of an external reality. .
ohhhh... aaahh... uhhhm.... NO thanks, you keep your sleepy whisper invisible friends to yourself mate, I'm good
That idealist nonsense is not grounded in material reality.
Religion is a post-hoc justification for imperialism. Britain didnt create Israel because of their religion, but because it was an effective way to get a colony and get rid of jews (lord Balfour was wildly antisemitic). American politicians who give Israel billions in weapons and political support dont get millions in campaign funds from Raytheon and co to get elected because of their religion, but because it benefits the military-industrial complex. The structure determines the super-structure; Ideology, culture, religion, etc are all molded to reinforce the relationship with the means of production.
That idealist nonsense is not grounded in material reality.
Religion is a post-hoc justification for imperialism.
bwahahaha....
pick a delusion already
m. Britain didnt create Israel because of their religion, but because it was an effective way to get a colony and get rid of jews (lord Balfour was wildly antisemitic).
they sold it twice. once to the orthodox and once to the Palestinians. a drunken stumble from the ottoman empire we're still coping with.
and now our idiotic evangelical nutbags are fueling their vision of the end times.
imagine if everyone stopped believing there was a higher power pushing them to this bonkers state